Impact of scattering phase function and polarization on the accuracy of diffuse and sub-diffuse spatial frequency domain imaging

Significance Although spatial frequency domain imaging (SFDI) has been well characterized under diffuse optical conditions, tissue measurements made outside the diffuse regime can provide new diagnostic information. Before such measurements can become clinically relevant, however, the behavior of sub-diffuse SFDI and its effect on the accuracy of derived tissue parameters must be assessed. Aim We aim to characterize the impact that both the assumed scattering phase function (SPF) and the polarization state of the illumination light source have on the accuracy of SFDI-derived optical properties when operating under diffuse or sub-diffuse conditions, respectively. Approach Through the use of a set of well-characterized optical phantoms, SFDI accuracy was assessed at four wavelengths (395, 545, 625, and 850 nm) and two different spatial frequencies (0.3 and 1.0 mm-1), which provided a broad range of diffuse and sub-diffuse conditions, using three different SPFs. To determine the effects of polarization, the SFDI accuracy was assessed using both unpolarized and cross-polarized illumination. Results It was found that the assumed SPF has a direct and significant impact on the accuracy of the SFDI-derived optical properties, with the best choice of SPF being dictated by the polarization state. As unpolarized SFDI retains the sub-diffuse portion of the signal, optical properties were found to be more accurate when using the full SPF that includes forward and backscattering components. By contrast, cross-polarized SFDI yielded accurate optical properties when using a forward-scattering SPF, matching the behavior of cross-polarization to attenuate the immediate backscattering of sub-diffuse reflectance. Using the correct pairings of SPF and polarization enabled using a reflectance standard, instead of a more subjective phantom, as the reference measurement. Conclusions These results provide the foundation for a more thorough understanding of SFDI and enable new applications of this technology in which sub-diffuse conditions dominate (e.g., mu a not less than mu s ') or high spatial frequencies are required.