The role of theta and gamma oscillations in item memory, source memory, and memory confidence

Theta and gamma oscillations have been linked to episodic memory processes in various studies. Both oscillations seem to be vital for processes guided by the medial temporal lobe, such as the retrieval of information from memory. While theta oscillations increase with successful memory, it is unclear what the unique contribution of theta is to various subcomponents of memory. On the other hand, memory-related gamma oscillations have been mainly reported in the hippocampus, leaving the role of neocortical gamma in memory underexplored. In this study, we investigated how unique variability in memory accuracy and memory confidence contributes to fluctuations in theta and gamma power. To this end, we recorded EEG from 54 participants while they performed a source memory task. From this task we obtained their item memory accuracy, source memory accuracy, item memory confidence, and source memory confidence. These behavioral measures were put in a trial-by-trial linear mixed effects model to uncover their unique contribution to the oscillatory power in frontal and parietal regions. Our results are in line with the involvement of theta oscillations in both memory accuracy and confidence, but seem to indicate a main role for theta oscillations in memory-related confidence. In addition, we found that gamma oscillations play various roles in memory processing, dependent on brain region. Utilizing a trial-by-trial model-based approach, we explored the specific contribution of brain oscillations to episodic memory retrieval. Our results support the notion that theta oscillations have a greater involvement in memory confidence than accuracy. In addition, neocortical gamma oscillations play a role in memory accuracy and confidence. This indicates that the primary role of theta is memory-related decision making and that gamma plays a role in memory processing, even when looking beyond the hippocampus.