The preference of Schistocerca americana (Drury) for 40 potential host plants relative to bahiagrass, Paspalum notatum, was determined in two-choice and four-choice tests. Although highly polyphagous, S. americana demonstrated clear preference and nonpreference for certain species. Host selection by small nymphs (instars 3 and 4), large nymphs (instars 5 and 6), and adults was highly correlated. Host selection by spring-generation grasshoppers was highly correlated with summer-generation host preference. The presence of alternate hosts, especially nonpreferred species, resulted in modified host-selection behavior wherein grasshoppers were more discriminating in four-choice tests than two-choice tests.