Aristotle and the Problem of Moral Responsibility: Pre-determinism or Indeterminism?

被引:0
|
作者
Andreazza, Tiaraju Molina [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Vale Rio dos Sinos, Filosofia, Sao Leopoldo, RS, Brazil
来源
PENSANDO-REVISTA DE FILOSOFIA | 2014年 / 5卷 / 10期
关键词
Indeterminism; Predeterminism; Voluntary;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
When discusses the voluntary acts, in EN III 1-5, Aristotle deals with two questions: (i) under which conditions someone can be morally responsible for his actions and (ii) when someone can be seen as free to act. Aristotle argues that we can be morally responsible only if is in our power to act and also it is in our power not to act. The aim of this essay is to analyze (i) and (ii), considering if the concept of "in our power" is used by Aristotle in an indeterminist or pre-determinist sense. It will be defended that there are textual references in favor of both interpretations, from which we can conclude that the question is unsolvable.
引用
收藏
页码:149 / 171
页数:23
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Biologic pre-determinism in colorectal cancer (CRC).
    Baig, KM
    Whatley, P
    Thompson, MR
    GUT, 1999, 44 : A16 - A16
  • [2] DETERMINISM, INDETERMINISM AND THE PROBLEM OF THE TRUE FUTURE
    Schieppati, Stefano Maria
    RIVISTA DI FILOSOFIA NEO-SCOLASTICA, 2018, 110 (1-2) : 171 - 184
  • [3] DETERMINISM AND MORAL RESPONSIBILITY
    MANDELBAUM, M
    ETHICS, 1960, 70 (03) : 204 - 219
  • [4] Moral responsibility and determinism
    da Fonseca, Tania Schneider
    ARGUMENTOS-REVISTA DE FILOSOFIA, 2016, (16): : 145 - 158
  • [5] Aristotle on moral responsibility
    Deslauriers, M
    DIALOGUE-CANADIAN PHILOSOPHICAL REVIEW, 1997, 36 (03) : 636 - 639
  • [6] Determinism, Moral Responsibility and Retribution
    Shaw, Elizabeth
    Blakey, Robert
    NEUROETHICS, 2020, 13 (01) : 99 - 113
  • [7] Determinism, Moral Responsibility and Retribution
    Elizabeth Shaw
    Robert Blakey
    Neuroethics, 2020, 13 : 99 - 113
  • [8] Moral Coincidence, moral Responsibility and causal Determinism
    Schaelike, Julius
    ZEITSCHRIFT FUR PHILOSOPHISCHE FORSCHUNG, 2013, 67 (03): : 351 - 370
  • [9] GENETIC DETERMINISM AND THE PROBLEM OF MORAL RESPONSIBILITY OR IS MORALITY POSSIBLE WITHOUT FREEDOM?
    Abramova, Anastasiya
    Abramova, Viktoria
    Vetrov, Vladimir
    Aleshina, Oksana
    WISDOM, 2022, 24 (04): : 37 - 47
  • [10] Aristotle on moral responsibility.
    Tuozzo, TM
    PHRONESIS-A JOURNAL FOR ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY, 1997, 42 (03): : 335 - 344