Mass violence and secession as reparation: the case of Kosovo

The interpretation of an act of mass violence is always a contentious issue since it confers a certain status to the targeted group. This status may become an important factor in the international community's decision to recognize or not the independence of a group and its territory. This article examines the case of Kosovo's February 2008 recognition by the international community and argues that this recognition was made possible by the summoning of arguments based on Kosovo Albanians' collective status as victims of ethnic cleansing. The article bridges the gap between on the one hand the Remedial Right theory of secession, and on the other hand, works on mass violence against ethnonational groups. The article shows that the practice of state recognition was reoriented towards a restrictive criterion linked to the type of violence sustained by the group claiming independence. Under this interpretation, territory becomes a tangible form of compensation for suffered injustices, which contrasts with earlier practice of state recognition in the former Yugoslavia and elsewhere.