Exposure to subfreezing temperature and a freeze-thaw cycle affect freezing tolerance of winter wheat in saturated soil

Winter wheat is sown in the autumn and harvested the following summer, necessitating the ability to survive subfreezing temperatures for several months. Autumn months in wheat-growing regions typically experience significant rainfall and several days or weeks of mild subfreezing temperatures at night, followed by above-freezing temperatures in the day. Hence, the wheat plants usually are first exposed to potentially damaging subfreezing temperatures when they have high moisture content, are growing in very wet soil, and have been exposed to freeze-thaw cycles for a period of time. These conditions are conducive to freezing stresses and plant responses that are different from those that occur under lower moisture conditions without freeze-thaw cycles. This study was conducted to investigate the impact of mild subfreezing temperature and a freeze-thaw cycle on the ability of 22 winter wheat cultivars to tolerate freezing in saturated soil. Seedlings that had been acclimated at +4°C for 5 weeks in saturated soil were frozen to potentially damaging temperatures under three treatment conditions: (1) without any subzero pre-freezing treatment; (2) with a 16-h period at −3°C prior to freezing to potentially damaging temperatures; and (3) with a freeze-thaw cycle of −3°C for 24 h followed by +4°C for 24 h, followed by a 16-h period at −3°C prior to freezing to potentially damaging temperatures. In general, plants that had been exposed to the freeze-thaw cycle survived significantly more frequently than plants frozen under the other two treatments. Plants that had been exposed to 16 h at −3° (without the freeze-thaw cycle) before freezing to potentially damaging temperatures survived significantly more frequently than plants that were frozen to potentially damaging temperatures without a subzero pre-freezing treatment. These results indicated that cold-acclimated wheat plants actively acclimate to freezing stress while exposed to mild subfreezing temperatures, and further acclimate when allowed to thaw at +4°C for 24 h. The cultivar Norstar had the lowest LT50 (temperature predicted to be lethal to 50% of the plants) of the 22 cultivars when frozen with either of the subzero pre-freezing treatments, but several cultivars had lower LT50 scores than Norstar when frozen without a subzero pre-freezing treatment. We conclude it may be possible to improve winterhardiness of wheat grown in saturated soil by combining the ability to effectively respond to mild subzero pre-freezing temperatures with a greater ability to withstand freezing to damaging temperatures without a subzero pre-freezing exposure.