Songs produced during heterosexual duets in a green lacewing, C. plorabunda, are sexually monomorphic. However, individuals of either sex will also engage in intrasexual duets, which can exhibit sexual dimorphism. We confined males and females together in various combinations in a small arena to study the phenotypes, behavioral interactions, and functional roles of duetting in this species. The goal was to test whether sexual selection or sex recognition provided the better explanation of song sexual dimorphism. We determined that the monomorphic form of the intrasexual duet was long and stable, and could take place either between males or between females. Such “standard” intrasexual duetting songs were acoustically indistinguishable from heterosexual songs. However, males could also engage other males in special “fast duets” that sped up and terminated abruptly. Equivalent fast duets were not part of the female repertory. Fast duetting songs between males differed significantly from other types of male or female duetting songs in every measurable characteristic, but their role in the mating system was ambiguous. Contrary to one prediction of the sexual selection hypothesis, fast duetting between males occurred less often in situations where it might be the most useful to males in securing mates, i.e., during male-male-female interactions (trios). In addition, fast songs that started, ended, both started and ended, or neither started nor ended duets were acoustically indistinguishable, making it unlikely that females were choosing males based on such variation. However, songs that “both started and ended” fast duets were associated with a significant mating advantage, indicating a possible role for fast duetting in male-male sexual competition. Because the alternative hypothesis of sex recognition was also supported by some of our results, we conclude that aggressive qualities of male-male fast duets probably mediate intrasexual selection, while their increasing tempo serves as an adaptive response to promote rapid sex recognition by truncating unproductive and potentially dangerous intrasexual duetting.
