The cooling efficiency of different dental high-speed handpiece coolant port designs

The study investigated the cooling efficiency of different numbers of water coolant ports on high-speed hand pieces (HSH) under cooling conditions used in clinical practice. Twenty-four groove cuts with water on and nine cuts without water were made on extracted human premolars using three HSHs with different port configurations. Thermocouples were placed in the pulp chambers and temperature changes were recorded with 1-, 3- and 4-coolant port handpieces. Cooling rate was calculated for each coolant port design system. Temperature changes were statistically analysed with Kruskal-Willis Test. All three sample groups resulted in a net temperature decrease during the cuffing period with water turned on. There was a pattern of increased cooling rate with increasing number of coolant ports (1-port-4.27 (+0.94) degrees C, 3-port: -4.66 (+/- 2.90) degrees C, 4-port: 5.03 (+/- 1.08) degrees C). The difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.681). Calculations of cooling rate showed a higher cooling rate with an increase in the number of ports (1-port 46.13 x 10(-4) K-1, 3-port: 51.36 x 10(-4) K-1, 4-port: 56.32 x 10(-4) K-1). In the dry tooth preparation samples, all resulted in a net increase in temperature (1-port 4.43 (+/- 3.30) degrees C, 3-port: 5.13 (+/- 3.27) degrees C, 4-port: 2.87 (+/- 2.97) degrees C). All the three water coolant port configurations showed effective cooling of the tooth during cuffing and decreased pulpal temperature with no statistical difference. There are HSH designs with varying numbers of coolant ports available in the market for clinicians. The results of the current study could potentially aid clinicians in making a decision while choosing between different dental handpieces.