EVALUATING THE IMPACT OF BRAZIL'S BOLSA FAMILIA Cash Transfer Programs in Comparative Perspective

This note reviews the targeting performance of Bolsa Familia and its impact on inequality, poverty, consumption, education, health care, and labor force participation. Bolsa Familia has several design and implementation characteristics that distance it from a pure human-capital-based conditional cash transfer model. For that reason, we compare the impact of Bolsa Familia to that of other conditional cash transfer programs in Latin America, such as in Mexico, Colombia, Ecuador, and Chile. We show that, as have other programs, Bolsa Familia has helped reduce inequality and extreme poverty and has improved education outcomes, without having a negative impact on labor force participation. Where the program has failed to have its intended impact, in health and nutrition, supply-side constraints seem to be the principal problem.