S-Lay installation of inline buckle arrestors in deep water can introduce plastic strain to girth welds. The welds are repeatedly loaded by large-strain cycles when traversing the stinger. A material-testing program was launched to assess the impact of this load sequence on the welds' integrity. It is essential to establish the correct mechanism of crack growth caused by a limited number of sequential large-strain cycles. Segment specimens with increased specimen "daylight" length were tested. Fracture morphologies of ductile tearing and fatigue growth were distinguished; ductile tearing was identified only for the first load cycle, whereas subsequent cycles were dominated by fatigue crack growth.