Abstract Explanations in Science

被引:68
|
作者
Pincock, Christopher [1 ]
机构
[1] Ohio State Univ, Dept Philosophy, Columbus, OH 43210 USA
来源
关键词
MATHEMATICS;
D O I
10.1093/bjps/axu016
中图分类号
N09 [自然科学史]; B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ; 010108 ; 060207 ; 060305 ; 0712 ;
摘要
This article focuses on a case that expert practitioners count as an explanation: a mathematical account of Plateau's laws for soap films. I argue that this example falls into a class of explanations that I call abstract explanations. Abstract explanations involve an appeal to a more abstract entity than the state of affairs being explained. I show that the abstract entity need not be causally relevant to the explanandum for its features to be explanatorily relevant. However, it remains unclear how to unify abstract and causal explanations as instances of a single sort of thing. I conclude by examining the implications of the claim that explanations require objective dependence relations. If this claim is accepted, then there are several kinds of objective dependence relations.
引用
收藏
页码:857 / 882
页数:26
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Strong Explanations in Abstract Argumentation
    Ulbricht, Markus
    Wallner, Johannes P.
    THIRTY-FIFTH AAAI CONFERENCE ON ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, THIRTY-THIRD CONFERENCE ON INNOVATIVE APPLICATIONS OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND THE ELEVENTH SYMPOSIUM ON EDUCATIONAL ADVANCES IN ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, 2021, 35 : 6496 - 6504
  • [2] Abstract versus Causal Explanations?
    Reutlinger, Alexander
    Andersen, Holly
    INTERNATIONAL STUDIES IN THE PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 2016, 30 (02) : 129 - 146
  • [3] On Computing Explanations in Abstract Argumentation
    Fan, Xiuyi
    Toni, Francesca
    21ST EUROPEAN CONFERENCE ON ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (ECAI 2014), 2014, 263 : 1005 - 1006
  • [4] EXPLANATIONS IN COGNITIVE SCIENCE
    BEARDON, C
    ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE REVIEW, 1988, 2 (03) : 181 - 193
  • [5] Computing Argument Preferences and Explanations in Abstract Argumentation
    Mahesar, Quratul-ain
    2018 IEEE 30TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON TOOLS WITH ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (ICTAI), 2018, : 281 - 285
  • [6] Smallest Explanations and Diagnoses of Rejection in Abstract Argumentation
    Niskanen, Andreas
    Jarvisalo, Matti
    KR2020: PROCEEDINGS OF THE 17TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON PRINCIPLES OF KNOWLEDGE REPRESENTATION AND REASONING, 2020, : 667 - 671
  • [7] Abstract Science?
    Hoffmann, Roald
    AMERICAN SCIENTIST, 2009, 97 (06) : 450 - 453
  • [8] Counterfactual Explanations for Misclassified Images: How Human and Machine Explanations Differ (Abstract Reprint)
    Delaney, Eoin
    Pakrashi, Arjun
    Greene, Derek
    Keane, Mark T.
    THIRTY-EIGHTH AAAI CONFERENCE ON ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, VOL 38 NO 20, 2024, : 22696 - 22696
  • [9] Envisioning explanations - the art in science
    Gooding, DC
    INTERDISCIPLINARY SCIENCE REVIEWS, 2004, 29 (03) : 278 - 294
  • [10] Explanations - Styles of explanation in science
    Cornwell, J
    Explanations: Styles of Explanation in Science, 2004, : XI - XXV