Reliability and validity of the DSM-IV diagnostic category of schizoaffective disorder: Preliminary data

Background: Concerns have been expressed about the reliability and validity of the DSM-IV criteria for schizoaffective disorder, but no systematic study has been published up to now. Methods: The Cohen's kappa for the individual items of the DSM-IV definition of schizoaffective disorder, manic episode and major depressive episode was evaluated in 150 patients independently interviewed by two psychiatrists using the Composite international Diagnostic Interview. The two-year outcome of patients with a consensus DSM-IV diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder was compared to that of patients with DSM-IV schizophrenia and schizophreniform disorder, using the Strauss-Carpenter Outcome Scale. Results: The Cohen's kappa was 0.22 for the diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder, 0.71 for that of manic episode, and 0.82 for that of major depressive episode. Schizoaffective patients had a significantly better outcome than those with schizophrenia but a worse outcome than those with schizophreniform disorder. Conclusions: The inter-rater reliability of the DSM-IV criteria for schizoaffective disorder is not satisfactory. The better outcome of DSM-IV schizoaffective disorder compared with schizophrenia seems to depend more on the inclusion, in the definition of schizophrenia but not in that of schizoaffective disorder, of the six-month duration and functional impairment criteria than on the different symptomatological patterns of the two conditions. Limitation: The size of the sample of patients fulfilling DSM-IV criteria for schizoaffective disorder was small. Clinical relevance: The study suggests that the clinical implications of the currently problematic diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder may be modest. (C) 2000 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.