'After years in the wilderness': The discourse of land claims in the new South Africa

This article examines land restitution in the new South Africa, and the intersecting roles of land-claiming communities, forcibly resettled from their land during the apartheid years, and the NGOs and - since 1994 - Government Commissioners who have helped them to reclaim the land. Ideas and practices concerning land, community and development that emerge from the interaction between these different players are mutually constitutive but sometimes also mutually incomprehensible. A populist rhetoric, evident both in discussions with former land owners, and in much of NGO publications such as Land Update, depicts land as something communally owned which must be communally defended. This sense of uniformly experienced injustice and shared resistance against outside intervention obscures the fact that claims on land derive from a series of sharply differentiated historical experiences and articulate widely divergent interests, such as those - in case of the farm Doornkop for example - between former owners and their former tenants. The restitution of land to these former owners, while of great importance to them as as source od identity and as a redress of past injustices, is not necessarily the key to solving 'poverty, injustice and misery' as claimed for the process of land reform in South Africa as a whole.