COMPARATIVE LEGAL ANALYSIS OF THE PROCEDURAL ARRANGEMENTS FOR ATTACHMENT OF EARNINGS OF A DEBTOR IN THE LAW OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND CHINA

被引:0
|
作者
Rusakova, Ekaterina [1 ]
Frolova, Evgenia [2 ]
Kupchina, Ekaterina [1 ]
Koshelev, Anton [1 ]
机构
[1] RUDN Univ, Moscow, Russia
[2] Inst Legislat & Comparat Law Govt Russian Federat, Law, Moscow, Russia
关键词
enforcement proceedings; execution creditor; debtor; salary; income; arrest; marshal; bailiff;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
G40 [教育学];
学科分类号
040101 ; 120403 ;
摘要
Enforcement proceedings in any country of the world are the most important institution of civil legal relations and in most cases is the final stage of the settlement of disagreements between the disputing parties. Forcible withdrawal of another's property based on court decisions restores the violated rights of parties and establishes the primacy of law in modern society. The organization of the enforcement proceedings, its internal structure, as well as the powers of the executive bodies in each country, is regulated based on the current needs of society, the legal system, and historical background. The similarities of executive legislation of different countries are the instruments of enforcement bodies, acting on the debtor in order to force him to perform the court decision in full. One of these tools, widely used by the bailiffs of the Russian Federation, is the foreclosure on the income of a debtor. The relatively simple enforcement procedure in the legislation of the Russian Federation related to the foreclosure by bailiffs leads to the law of the country, which is the leader in dispute resolution in the Asia-Pacific region, namely, the law of China, in order to compare the relevant procedural rules and determine potential opportunities for improvement of legal mechanisms governing the considered method of enforcement proceedings. This article provides a comparative analysis of the procedural rules governing the garnishment of wages and other income of a debtor in China and the Russian Federation. The result of the study is to identify the advantages and disadvantages of the process of implementing this method of enforcement proceedings and develop recommendations for further improvement of the legislation in the countries under consideration. To achieve this goal, the following tasks are defined: - To identify and analyze procedural legislation governing the process of foreclosure on the income of a debtor in Russia and China in enforcement proceedings; - To identify the trends in the reform of procedural legislation on the enforcement proceedings of the Russian Federation and China; - To develop recommendations for the implementation of the right to enforcement proceedings in these countries. The methodological basis of the study consists of general scientific methods of cognition, including systemic, formal-logical, structural-functional analysis, as well as specific legal methods: comparative legal and formal legal. The scientific novelty of the study is a comprehensive study of enforcement proceedings and consideration of the possibility of borrowing the approach of China into enforcement proceedings in the Russian Federation. A comparative analysis of the legislation on enforcement proceedings of the Russian Federation and China, governing the foreclosure on the debtor income, was carried out using methods of logical and statistical analysis, general scientific and specific oriented methodology. The results of this study can be used in the development of legal acts, regulating enforcement proceedings, as well as to improve the legislation of the countries in question. The authors do not object if the conclusions and materials of this article are used in research activities, law enforcement practice, teaching, during lectures and seminars on the civil process and private international law.
引用
收藏
页码:159 / 165
页数:7
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Procedural independence of the investigator (comparative legal analysis of the legislation of the Russian Federation and the Socialist Republic of Vietnam)
    Ivanov, Dmitriy Aleksandrovich
    Dung, Vo Kim
    Skachko, Anna Vladilenovna
    Fadeev, Pavel Vladimirovich
    Potapov, Vasily Dzhonovich
    JUSTICIA, 2022, 27 (42) : 155 - 160
  • [2] Law and legal system of the Russian Federation
    Kahn, Jeffrey
    REVIEW OF CENTRAL AND EAST EUROPEAN LAW, 2008, 33 (02) : 239 - 247
  • [3] Advocate Specification in the Russian Empire and the Russian Federation (comparative law analysis)
    Ivanovich, Cherepanov Sergey
    LEGAL SCIENCE AND PRACTICE-BULLETIN OF NIZHNIY NOVGOROD ACADEMY OF THE MINISTRY IF THE INTERIOR OF RUSSIA, 2015, 31 (03): : 237 - 242
  • [4] COMPARATIVE LEGAL ANALYSIS OF HEALTH SYSTEMS IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND SWITZERLAND
    Gusakova, Yuliya S.
    Vladislavovich, Krotov Andrey
    Kuzmina, Alevtina V.
    Ragozina, Natalia A.
    Shvets, Yuri Y.
    REVISTA GENERO & DIREITO, 2020, 9 (04): : 947 - 954
  • [5] Exercising Digital Rights in Procedural Law of Russian Federation
    Starinov, G. P.
    Tseveleva, I., V
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2ND INTERNATIONAL SCIENTIFIC AND PRACTICAL CONFERENCE - MODERN MANAGEMENT TRENDS AND THE DIGITAL ECONOMY: FROM REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT TO GLOBAL ECONOMIC GROWTH (MTDE 2020), 2020, 138 : 469 - 473
  • [6] Law and legal system of the Russian federation.
    Hendley, K
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF COMPARATIVE LAW, 2000, 48 (02): : 337 - 342
  • [7] LEGAL STATUS OF A CHILD IN FAMILY LEGISLATION OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND CIS: COMPARATIVE LEGAL ANALYSIS
    Letova, Natalya
    Kozhokar, Igor
    RUSSIAN LAW JOURNAL, 2019, 7 (03) : 82 - 106
  • [8] Terms of office of the magistrate in the Russian empire and the Russian Federation (comparative-legal analysis)
    Andreevich, Volosatykh Evgeniy
    LEGAL SCIENCE AND PRACTICE-BULLETIN OF NIZHNIY NOVGOROD ACADEMY OF THE MINISTRY IF THE INTERIOR OF RUSSIA, 2016, (02): : 62 - 66
  • [9] COMPARATIVE LEGAL ANALYSIS OF FUNCTIONS OF PROSECUTION IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN
    Akhmetova, A. B.
    BULLETIN OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN, 2014, (05): : 109 - 113
  • [10] CORPORATE LEGAL ENTITIES IN THE CIVIL LAW OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION
    Sitdikova, Lubov
    Starodumova, Svetlana
    Volkova, Maria
    ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT, 2018, : 715 - 721