Does the threat of longer prison terms reduce the incidence of assault?

被引:4
|
作者
Menendez, Patricia [1 ]
Weatherburn, Don James [1 ]
机构
[1] NSW Bur Crime Stat & Res, Sydney, NSW, Australia
来源
关键词
Assault; liquor licensing; mandatory minimum penalties; Standard non-parole periods; structural time series analysis; GENERAL DETERRENCE; SEVERITY; PUNISHMENT; CERTAINTY; CELERITY; MODEL;
D O I
10.1177/0004865815575397
中图分类号
DF [法律]; D9 [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
In a bid to reduce alcohol-related violence, the New South Wales Government recently proposed introducing mandatory minimum prison terms for assault. This article addresses the question of whether the threat of mandatory minimum penalties would reduce the incidence of assault. We exploit an earlier sentencing reform in New South Wales (the introduction of standard non-parole periods) in which longer minimum periods in custody were announced but never actually carried into effect. We use time series structural modelling to see whether assault rates in New South Wales were affected by the threat of more severe penalties. No evidence is found that the threat of longer prison terms had any effect on the incidence of assault in New South Wales. The article discusses the policy implications of this finding and concludes that liquor licensing policy is a more cost-effective policy instrument for dealing with alcohol-related violence than sentencing policy.
引用
收藏
页码:389 / 404
页数:16
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Does visitation in prison reduce recidivism?
    Otsu, Yuki
    JOURNAL OF POLICY ANALYSIS AND MANAGEMENT, 2024, 43 (01) : 126 - 156
  • [2] FEDERAL SENTENCING GUIDELINES GENERATE MORE PRISON SENTENCES AND LONGER TERMS IN TAX CASES
    LACEWELL, LA
    TIGUE, JJ
    JOURNAL OF TAXATION, 1993, 79 (01): : 40 - 43
  • [3] Does a common ingroup identity reduce intergroup threat?
    Riek, Blake M.
    Mania, Eric W.
    Gaertner, Samuel L.
    McDonald, Stacy A.
    Lamoreaux, Marika J.
    GROUP PROCESSES & INTERGROUP RELATIONS, 2010, 13 (04) : 403 - 423
  • [4] Altitude Does Not Reduce Concussion Incidence: Response
    Smith, David W.
    Myer, Gregory D.
    Comstock, R. Dawn
    Clark, Joseph F.
    Bailes, Julian E.
    ORTHOPAEDIC JOURNAL OF SPORTS MEDICINE, 2014, 2 (03):
  • [5] Does laparoscopy reduce the incidence of unnecessary appendicectomies?
    Barrat, C
    Catheline, JM
    Rizk, N
    Champault, GG
    SURGICAL LAPAROSCOPY & ENDOSCOPY, 1999, 9 (01) : 27 - 31
  • [6] Does laparoscopy reduce the incidence of useless appendectomies?
    Barrat, C
    Champault, G
    Catheline, JM
    Rizk, N
    Ziol, M
    Guettier, C
    ANNALES DE CHIRURGIE, 1998, 52 (10): : 965 - 969
  • [7] Premedication and Longer Infusion Time Do Not Reduce the Incidence of Hypersensitivity Reactions to Pegaspargase
    Hughes, Catherine
    Bernardo, Valeria
    Youssef, Susanne
    Hughes, James P.
    Keller, Frank G.
    Miller, Tamara P.
    Castellino, Sharon M.
    Lew, Glen
    BLOOD, 2020, 136
  • [8] Size of the needle for infant vaccination - Longer needles reduce incidence of local reactions
    Zimmerman, Richard Kent
    BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2006, 333 (7568): : 563 - 564
  • [9] Commentary on Kypri & Livingston (2020): Alcohol trading hour restrictions reduce assault incidence
    Foulds, James A.
    ADDICTION, 2020, 115 (11) : 2055 - 2056
  • [10] Bladder neck conserving prostatectomy does not reduce the incidence
    Hausmann, Ralph
    AKTUELLE UROLOGIE, 2009, 40 (02) : 64 - 64