Chloroethene Biotransformation in the Presence of Different Sulfate Concentrations

This paper aims to reconcile discrepancies among reports of dechlorination performance in the presence of sulfate, by analyzing data from the literature, presenting results from laboratory experiments performed with mixed anaerobic microbial cultures, and synthesizing respective findings. A complete set of metrics for dechlorination progress was developed and used in the analysis of selected field and laboratory studies. When differences in site and experimental conditions are accounted for and definitions of dechlorination completeness are harmonized, the inverse relationship between dechlorination performance and sulfate concentration becomes clearer. This relationship was investigated in detail with laboratory experiments on mixed anaerobic microbial cultures enriched with the same concentration of trichloroethylene (TCE) and different sulfate concentrations, equal to near zero (considered as the baseline culture), 30, 400, and 1100 mg/L. In all experiments, sulfate reduction proceeded concurrently with dechlorination. The observed behavior was bimodal, indicating a transition in dechlorination performance between 30 and 400 mg/L. Under low donor to acceptor stoichiometry conditions, TCE dechlorination was incomplete in all experiments after 14 days, while the percentage of TCE moles reduced to vinyl chloride was lower by about 50% in the experiments with high sulfate concentrations. When donor was added in excess to stoichiometry needs for TCE reduction, TCE dechlorination was complete in the baseline culture, while only little ethene was detected in the high sulfate concentration cultures. When all studies are considered together, it appears that the presence of sulfate does not preclude complete dechlorination but rather delays it. Data analysis also suggests that the proposed upper limit of 500 mg/L for the range of initial sulfate concentration that is not problematic for dechlorination should be revised to a lower value.