A "quota silo" or positive equality reach? The equality impact of gender quotas on corporate boards in Norway

被引:16
|
作者
Seierstad, Cathrine [1 ]
Healy, Geraldine [2 ]
Goldeng, Eskil Sonju Le Bruyn [1 ]
Fjellvaer, Hilde [3 ]
机构
[1] Univ South Eastern Norway, Dept Business Hist & Social Sci, Sch Business, Campus Vestfold, N-3184 Borre, Norway
[2] Queen Mary Univ London, Sch Business & Management, London, England
[3] Norwegian Univ Sci & Technol NTNU, NTNU Business Sch, Trondheim, Norway
关键词
equality reach; gender quotas; inequality regimes; quota silo; spillover; women on boards; DIVERSITY; WOMEN; DIRECTORS; BALANCE;
D O I
10.1111/1748-8583.12288
中图分类号
F24 [劳动经济];
学科分类号
020106 ; 020207 ; 1202 ; 120202 ;
摘要
10 years after its implementation, we explore the equality reach of the 40% Norwegian gender quota regulation for boards of public limited companies (PLCs) using a multi-strategy approach (administrative data and interviews with women directors) to capture interrelated macro and meso changes. We employ Acker's (2006) inequality regimes as our analytical framework, augmented by the "equality reach" concept. We found strong compliance with the 40% Quota. However, there was little evidence of voluntary spillover to limited companies as envisaged by Quota proponents; instead Quota coverage reduced as some PLCs changed status to avoid the Quota requirement. We reveal that positive equality reach in one of the most equal countries in the world is confined to a PLC "quota silo," which has shrunk over the life of the Quota. Moreover, we suggest that PLC high levels of compliance may be a defensive strategy seen as necessary in the regulatory/high sanction context of the Quota. We demonstrate the need for further political and organisational interventions to improve equality reach beyond the quota silo. We also show the value of the equality reach concept for research on equality interventions and warn of the dangers of an intervention leading to an equality silo.
引用
收藏
页码:165 / 186
页数:22
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Gender Quotas on Corporate Boards: Similarities and Differences in Quota Scenarios
    Mensi-Klarbach, Heike
    Seierstad, Cathrine
    EUROPEAN MANAGEMENT REVIEW, 2020, 17 (03) : 615 - 631
  • [2] Corporate Board Quotas and Gender Equality Policies in the Workplace
    Latura, Audrey
    Weeks, Ana Catalano
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE, 2023, 67 (03) : 606 - 622
  • [3] Gender equality within boards: comparing quota and soft law
    Harnay, Sophie
    Llense, Fabienne
    Reberioux, Antoine
    Roudaut, Gwenael
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF LAW AND ECONOMICS, 2024, 57 (1-2) : 1 - 35
  • [4] Gender equality within boards: comparing quota and soft law
    Sophie Harnay
    Fabienne Llense
    Antoine Rebérioux
    Gwenaël Roudaut
    European Journal of Law and Economics, 2024, 57 : 1 - 35
  • [5] The Impact of Gender Quotas on Gender Equality in Sport Governance
    Adriaanse, Johanna
    Schofield, Toni
    JOURNAL OF SPORT MANAGEMENT, 2014, 28 (05) : 485 - 497
  • [6] Broadening of the Field of Corporate Boards and Legitimate Capitals: An Investigation into the Use of Gender Quotas in Corporate Boards in Norway
    Seierstad, Cathrine
    Tatli, Ahu
    Aldossari, Maryam
    Huse, Morten
    WORK EMPLOYMENT AND SOCIETY, 2021, 35 (04) : 753 - 773
  • [7] GENDER EQUALITY WITHOUT GENDER QUOTAS Dilemmas in the Danish Approach to Gender Equality and Citizenship
    Agustin, Lise Rolandsen
    Siim, Birte
    Borchorst, Anette
    TRANSFORMING GENDER CITIZENSHIP: THE IRRESISTIBLE RISE OF GENDER QUOTAS IN EUROPE, 2018, : 400 - 423
  • [8] Gender Quotas for Legislatures and Corporate Boards
    Hughes, Melanie M.
    Paxton, Pamela
    Krook, Mona Lena
    ANNUAL REVIEW OF SOCIOLOGY, VOL 43, 2017, 43 : 331 - 352
  • [9] GENDER EQUALITY WITHOUT LEGISLATED QUOTAS IN SWEDEN
    Freidenvall, Lenita
    TRANSFORMING GENDER CITIZENSHIP: THE IRRESISTIBLE RISE OF GENDER QUOTAS IN EUROPE, 2018, : 366 - 399
  • [10] Gender Equality and Corporate Governance: Policy Strategies in Norway and New Zealand
    Casey, Catherine
    Skibnes, Renate
    Pringle, Judith K.
    GENDER WORK AND ORGANIZATION, 2011, 18 (06): : 613 - 630