Of malevolence and morality: Psychopathy dimensions are conducive to helping in highly-distressing moral dilemmas

We proposed a context-dependent account of psychopathy and morality which argues that any psychopathy dimension-including those typically theorized to be maladaptive-can be conducive to helping others under appropriate contexts. In Study 1, a college sample (N = 331; M-age = 18.68) completed two-factor and Triarchic psychopathy measures and reported helping behavior, psychological distress, and task prioritization (i.e., greater attentional focus on helping execution vs. helping consequences) after simulating highly-distressing moral dilemmas. In Study 2, a college sample (N = 256; M-age = 18.55) completed the same psychopathy measures and selected one of five intervention tasks-incrementally ranging from slightly to extremely distress-inducing-for an ostensible phobic to perform under conditions in which more distressing tasks were framed as either helpful or harmful. In Study 1, psychopathy dimensions were related to greater helping, which was generally explained best by greater task prioritization. In Study 2, psychopathy dimensions generally related to selecting more distressing tasks for the phobic, even when more distressing tasks were framed as helpful. Thus, psychopathy dimensions appeared conducive to helping in highly-distressing moral dilemmas. Findings contribute preliminary empirical support for a context-dependent account and the possibility of moral manifestations within psychopathy.