Meta-analysis of handsewn versus stapled reversal of loop ileostomy

被引:28
|
作者
Markides, Georgios A. [1 ]
Wijetunga, Imeshi U. [1 ]
Brown, Steve R. [2 ]
Anwar, Suhail [1 ]
机构
[1] Calderdale & Huddersfield NHS Trust, Dept Colorectal Surg, Huddersfield, W Yorkshire, England
[2] No Gen Hosp, Dept Gen Surg, Sheffield S5 7AU, S Yorkshire, England
关键词
handsewn anastomosis; ileostomy; reversal; stapled anastomosis; LOW ANTERIOR RESECTION; LOW RECTAL-CANCER; ANASTOMOTIC LEAKAGE; DEFUNCTIONING STOMA; CLOSURE; COMPLICATIONS; SURGERY; TRIAL; CONSTRUCTION; MORBIDITY;
D O I
10.1111/ans.12684
中图分类号
R61 [外科手术学];
学科分类号
摘要
BackgroundThe morbidity associated with closure of loop ileostomy (LI) may be attributed to the various surgical techniques employed for the closure. The purpose of this review was to review the hand-sutured (HS) versus the stapled anastomosis (SA) techniques, used in the reversal of LI. MethodsThe MEDLINE, PubMed, CINHAL, Cochrane library and Web of Knowledge databases were searched for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and case-control trials (CCTs), evaluating HS and SA in reversal of LI. Data extraction with risk of bias assessment was followed by subgroup and pooled data meta-analysis where applicable per outcome. ResultsFour RCTs (HS: 321, SA: 328) and 10 CCTs (HS: 2808, SA: 1044) were identified, with a total of 4508 patients. Regardless of subgroup analysis, no difference was seen between the two techniques with regard to anastomotic leaks (P = 0.24, odds ratio (OR): 1.37, 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.81-2.29) or re-operation. The stapled group showed a significantly lower rate of conservatively managed small bowel obstruction (SBO)/ ileus at 30 days (P < 0.001, OR: 2.27, 95% CI: 1.59-2.96) (P < 0.001) and SBO during combined short- and long-term follow-up (P < 0.001). The SA also showed significant shorter operative time (P = 0.02; WMD 11.52min), time to first bowel opening (P < 0.001; WMD 0.52 days) and length of hospital stay (P = 0.03; WMD 0.70 days). ConclusionThe stapled technique offers an advantage in terms of lower post-operative subacute SBO rates, a faster operative technique and shorter hospitalization times. These perceived benefits make it potentially superior to HS for the reversal of LI.
引用
收藏
页码:217 / 224
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND META-ANALYSIS OF HANDSEWN VERSUS STAPLED REVERSAL OF LOOP ILEOSTOMY
    Markides, G.
    Wijetunga, I.
    Brown, S.
    Anwar, S.
    Saeed, M.
    DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM, 2014, 57 (05) : E337 - E338
  • [2] Comparison of Stapled versus Handsewn Loop Ileostomy Closure: A Meta-analysis
    Terry T. W. Leung
    Anthony R. MacLean
    W. Donald Buie
    Elijah Dixon
    Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery, 2008, 12 : 939 - 944
  • [3] Comparison of stapled versus handsewn loop ileostomy closure: A meta-analysis
    Leung, Terry T. W.
    MacLean, Anthony R.
    Buie, W. Donald
    Dixon, Elijah
    JOURNAL OF GASTROINTESTINAL SURGERY, 2008, 12 (05) : 939 - 944
  • [4] Comparison of handsewn with stapled loop ileostomy closures
    Hull, TL
    Kobe, I
    Fazio, VW
    DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM, 1996, 39 (10) : 1086 - 1089
  • [5] Hand-Sewn versus Stapled Closure of Loop Ileostomy: A Meta-Analysis
    Madani, Rana
    Day, Nigel
    Kumar, Lalit
    Tilney, Henry S.
    Gudgeon, Andrew Mark
    DIGESTIVE SURGERY, 2019, 36 (03) : 183 - 194
  • [6] Laparoscopic versus open loop ileostomy reversal: A systematic review and meta-analysis
    Mckechnie, Tyler
    Tessier, Tea
    Anpalagan, Tharani
    Chu, Megan
    Lee, Yung
    Logie, Kathleen
    Doumouras, Aristithes
    Amin, Nalin
    Hong, Dennis
    Eskicioglu, Cagla
    SURGERY IN PRACTICE AND SCIENCE, 2023, 13
  • [7] Stapled vs hand suture closure of loop ileostomy: a meta-analysis
    Gong, J.
    Guo, Z.
    Li, Y.
    Gu, L.
    Zhu, W.
    Li, J.
    Li, N.
    COLORECTAL DISEASE, 2013, 15 (10) : e561 - e568
  • [8] Revisiting stapled and handsewn loop ileostomy closures: a large retrospective series
    Balik, Emre
    Eren, Tunc
    Bugra, Dursun
    Buyukuncu, Yilmaz
    Akyuz, Ali
    Yamaner, Sumer
    CLINICS, 2011, 66 (11) : 1935 - 1941
  • [9] REVERSAL OF LOOP ILEOSTOMY UNDER AN ENHANCED RECOVERY PROTOCOL; IS THE STAPLED TECHNIQUE STILL BETTER THAN THE HANDSEWN ANASTOMOSIS?
    Markides, G.
    McMahon, M.
    Wijetunga, I.
    Subramanian, A.
    Gupta, P.
    Holdsworth, P.
    Anwar, S.
    Saeed, M.
    DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM, 2014, 57 (05) : E247 - E247
  • [10] Stapled versus handsewn intestinal anastomosis in emergency laparotomy: A systemic review and meta-analysis
    Naumann, David N.
    Bhangu, Aneel
    Kelly, Michael
    Bowley, Douglas M.
    SURGERY, 2015, 157 (04) : 609 - 618