No significant difference between 1940 and 1470 nm in endovenous laser ablation using an in vitro porcine liver model

Current endovenous laser ablation (EVLA) practice favours 1470 nm, as water is a major chromophore for this wavelength. Water has a greater affinity for 1940 nm, leading to claims that lower powers or linear endovenous energy densities (LEEDs) are needed. We compared the thermal spread and carbonisation of EVLA using these two wavelengths, in the porcine liver model. Using the previously validated porcine liver model, we performed 5 treatments, at each power: 2 W, 4 W, 6 W, 8 W and 10 W using a standard pullback of 8 s/cm. This gave LEEDs for each wavelength of 16, 32, 48, 64 and 80 J/cm. Digital images were given random codes and analysed by two blinded observers. Thermal spread was measured using "SketchandCalc" online software and graded carbonisation from 0 (none) to 3 (black carbon tract). There was no significant difference in thermal spread between the two wavelengths at 6 W, 8 W and 10 W. At 2 W, the 1470-nm laser had a significantly increased thermal spread over the 1940 nm. Significantly more carbonisation was found with the 1940-nm laser compared to 1470 nm. In this model, there was no significant difference in thermal spread at powers of 6 W and more. At 2 W and potentially 4 W, 1470 nm showed spread than 1940 nm, due to increased absorption at the device/tissue interface. At powers and LEEDs used for saphenous ablation, we found no evidence to support reduced power or LEED when using 1940 nm. However, 1940 nm may be more advantageous than 1470 nm when ablating small thin-walled veins, near to the skin.