Effects of Fact-Checking Political Misinformation on Perceptual Accuracy and Epistemic Political Efficacy

被引:19
|
作者
York, Chance [1 ]
Ponder, James D. [2 ]
Humphries, Zach [3 ,4 ]
Goodall, Catherine [2 ]
Beam, Michael [2 ]
Winters, Carrie [2 ]
机构
[1] Kent State Univ, Sch Journalism & Mass Commun, Kent, OH 44242 USA
[2] Kent State Univ, Sch Commun Studies, Kent, OH 44242 USA
[3] Kent State Univ, Coll Commun & Informat, Kent, OH 44242 USA
[4] Averett Univ, Dept Commun Studies & Journalism, Commun, Danville, VA USA
关键词
fact-checking; political misinformation; epistemic political efficacy (EPE); fake news; vaccination; JOURNALISTIC ADJUDICATION; CORRECTING MYTHS; SELF-EFFICACY; NEWS; MISPERCEPTIONS; PARTISANSHIP; MESSAGES; BELIEFS;
D O I
10.1177/1077699019890119
中图分类号
G2 [信息与知识传播];
学科分类号
05 ; 0503 ;
摘要
Numerous studies have shown fact-checks can debunk misinformation and improve perceptions of reality surrounding a specific political issue. We examine whether fact-checks might also boost epistemic political efficacy (EPE), which is confidence in one's ability they can perceive reality surrounding political issues in general. Using a survey experiment (N = 1,139), we find discrediting misinformation with a fact-check increases accuracy in issue perceptions and, indirectly, EPE. However, fact-checking's direct effect on EPE is negative, suggesting fact-checks generally help individuals perform an immediate cognitive task-deciding which aspects of a political issue are true-while weakening confidence in task performance.
引用
收藏
页码:958 / 980
页数:23
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Network Informational Complexity, Epistemic Political Efficacy, and Fact-Checking
    Hopp, Toby
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF COMMUNICATION, 2024, 18 : 1028 - 1048
  • [2] The epistemic status of reproducibility in political fact-checking
    Alejandro Fernández-Roldan
    David Teira
    European Journal for Philosophy of Science, 2024, 14
  • [3] The epistemic status of reproducibility in political fact-checking
    Fernandez-Roldan, Alejandro
    Teira, David
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL FOR PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 2024, 14 (01)
  • [4] Fact-checking as a deterrent? A conceptual replication of the influence of fact-checking on the sharing of misinformation by political elites
    Ma, Siyuan
    Bergan, Daniel
    Ahn, Suhwoo
    Carnahan, Dustin
    Gimby, Nate
    McGraw, Johnny
    Virtue, Isabel
    HUMAN COMMUNICATION RESEARCH, 2023, 49 (03) : 321 - 338
  • [5] The Role of Political Devotion in Sharing Partisan Misinformation and Resistance to Fact-Checking
    Pretus, Clara
    Servin-Barthet, Camila
    Harris, Elizabeth A.
    Brady, William J.
    Vilarroya, Oscar
    Van Bavel, Jay J.
    JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-GENERAL, 2023, 152 (11) : 3116 - 3134
  • [6] Influence of Political Affiliation and Criticism on the Effectiveness of Political Fact-Checking
    Jarman, Jeffrey W.
    COMMUNICATION RESEARCH REPORTS, 2016, 33 (01) : 9 - 15
  • [7] Assessing the consistency of fact-checking in political debates
    Lelo, Thales
    JOURNAL OF COMMUNICATION, 2023, 73 (06) : 587 - 600
  • [8] Misinformation and children's fact-checking
    Bisla, Isaac
    Koenig, Melissa A.
    NATURE HUMAN BEHAVIOUR, 2024, 8 (12): : 2275 - 2276
  • [9] The limits of live fact-checking: Epistemological consequences of introducing a breaking news logic to political fact-checking
    Steensen, Steen
    Kalsnes, Bente
    Westlund, Oscar
    NEW MEDIA & SOCIETY, 2024, 26 (11) : 6347 - 6365
  • [10] Network segregation in a model of misinformation and fact-checking
    Tambuscio M.
    Oliveira D.F.M.
    Ciampaglia G.L.
    Ruffo G.
    Journal of Computational Social Science, 2018, 1 (2): : 261 - 275