Estrous characteristics and reproductive outcomes of Holstein heifers treated with 2 prostaglandin formulations and detected in estrus by an automated estrous detection or mounting device

Dinoprost tromethamine (DIN), a molecule similar to endogenous PGF(2 alpha), has a half-life of approximately 9 min. Cloprostenol sodium (CLO), a synthetic analog of PGF(2 alpha), has a half-life of approximately 3 h. We hypothesized that treatment of Holstein heifers with CLO would improve estrous detection rate, estrous characteristics, service rate, and overall reproductive performance compared with DIN. Currently in the United States, heifers are largely inseminated based on signs of estrus, which is detected visually or with the aid of mounting detection devices (MD). Automated estrous detection devices (AED) are becoming more accessible to producers, but it is not clear whether they present advantages in the reproductive management of heifers. Therefore, we hypothesized that the use of an AED would improve service and pregnancy rates compared with detection of estrus with the aid of a MD. holstein heifers (n = 1,019) were enrolled in the experiment at 10 to 11 mo of age, when they were fitted with a Heatime HR LD System (SCR Ltd., Netanya, Israel). At 12 mo of age, we paired heifers according to estrous cycle phase and randomly assigned them to treatments in a 2 x 2 design: PCF2 alpha formulation (CLO vs. DIN) and estrous detection treatment (AED vs. MD). Heifers in the AED treatment were detected in estrus only by the Heatime HR LD System, whereas heifers in the MD treatment were detected in estrus only by the Kamar Heatmount Detector (Kamar Products Inc., Zionsville, IN). Treatments with the same PGF(2 alpha) formulations were repeated 14 d after the first treatment if heifers had not been detected in estrus. A sub-group of heifers had blood sampled on the day of PGF(2 alpha) treatment and within 24 h of onset of estrus to determine progester- one and estradiol concentrations. Treatment with CLO reduced the progesterone concentration within 24 h of onset of estrus compared with DIN (0.04 +/- 0.01 vs. 0.11 +/- 0.01 ng/mL). Among heifers in mid diestrus on the day of PGF(2 alpha) treatment, CLO reduced the interval to estrus compared with DIN (72.0 +/- 2.2 vs. 82.4 +/- 2.4 h). Prostaglandin F-2 alpha formulation and estrous detection treatment did not affect pregnancy to the first service. The interval between the first and second services tended to be reduced for the AED treatment compared with the MD treatment (24.4 +/- 0.5 vs. 25.7 +/- 0.6 d). Prostaglandin F-2 alpha formulation and estrous detection treatment did not affect the hazard of pregnancy. Although CLO treatment may shorten the interval to estrus in heifers at mid diestrus compared with DIN, PGF(2 alpha) formulation did not affect reproductive performance. In the current experiment, no advantages in reproductive performance were observed when estrous detection was based on an AED compared with a MD.