Category mistakes: A barrier to effective environmental management

被引:14
|
作者
Wallace, Ken J. [1 ]
Jago, Mark [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Western Australia, UWA Sch Agr & Environm, 35 Stirling Hwy, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia
[2] Univ Nottingham, Dept Philosophy, Humanities Bldg,Univ Pk, Nottingham NG7 2RD, England
关键词
Planning; Decision-making; Natural resource management; Linguistic uncertainty; Ontological categories; ECOSYSTEM SERVICES; COMMON MISTAKES; HUMAN-VALUES; CLASSIFICATION; BIODIVERSITY; DIVERSITY; ECOLOGY;
D O I
10.1016/j.jenvman.2017.05.029
中图分类号
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号
08 ; 0830 ;
摘要
How entities, the things that exist, are defined and categorised affects all aspects of environmental management including technical descriptions, quantitative analyses, participatory processes, planning, and decisions. Consequently, ambiguous definitions and wrongly assigning entities to categories, referred to as category mistakes, are barriers to effective management. Confusion caused by treating the term 'biodiversity' variously as the property of an area, the biota of an area, and a preferred end state (a value) - quite different categories of entities - is one example. To overcome such difficulties, we develop and define four entity categories - elements, processes, properties, and values - and two derived categories - states and systems. We argue that adoption of these categories and definitions will significantly improve environmental communication and analysis, and thus strengthen planning and decision making. (C) 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:13 / 20
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Category Mistakes
    Bateman, John A.
    PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY, 2016, 66 (263): : 402 - 405
  • [2] Category Mistakes
    Szabo, Zoltan Gendler
    PHILOSOPHICAL REVIEW, 2015, 124 (02): : 289 - 292
  • [3] Category Mistakes
    Camp, Elisabeth
    MIND, 2016, 125 (498) : 611 - 615
  • [4] Effective category management depends on the role of the category
    Dhar, SK
    Hoch, SJ
    Kumar, N
    JOURNAL OF RETAILING, 2001, 77 (02) : 165 - 184
  • [5] Category Mistakes Electrified
    Mankowitz, Poppy
    REVIEW OF PHILOSOPHY AND PSYCHOLOGY, 2024, 15 (03) : 863 - 883
  • [6] Category mistakes are meaningful
    Ofra Magidor
    Linguistics and Philosophy, 2009, 32 : 553 - 581
  • [7] CATEGORY MISTAKES AND CLASSIFICATION
    SHARPE, R
    INQUIRY-AN INTERDISCIPLINARY JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 1967, 10 (1-2): : 204 - 207
  • [8] Category mistakes are meaningful
    Magidor, Ofra
    LINGUISTICS AND PHILOSOPHY, 2009, 32 (06) : 553 - 581
  • [9] Category mistakes on a plane
    不详
    TPM-THE PHILOSOPHERS MAGAZINE, 2015, (68): : 8 - 8
  • [10] Gaps in US livestock data are a barrier to effective environmental and disease management
    Logsdon Muenich, Rebecca
    Aryal, Sanskriti
    Ashworth, Amanda J.
    Bell, Michelle L.
    Boudreau, Melanie R.
    Cunningham, Stephanie A.
    Flynn, K. Colton
    Hamilton, Kerry A.
    Liu, Ting
    Mashtare, Michael L.
    Nelson, Natalie G.
    Rashid, Barira
    Saha, Arghajeet
    Schaffer-Smith, Danica
    Showalter, Callie
    Tchamdja, Aureliane
    Thompson, Jada
    ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS, 2025, 20 (03):