Tumor heterogeneity in ovarian cancer as demonstrated by in vitro chemoresistance assays

Objective. Tumor heterogeneity has been demonstrated in solid turners. In vitro assays were developed in an effort to predict in viva tumor response to therapy. We compare the in vitro assay results from multiple synchronous tumor samples in primary and recurrent ovarian cancers. Methods. 38 patients underwent surgery for primary (1 S) or recurrent (20) ovarian cancer. Two (22) or three (16) samples were obtained per patient and tested using the EDR assay (Oncotech, Inc.). The percentage of Extreme (E), Intermediate (I) and Low (L) drug resistance for each chemotherapy was compared between synchronous specimens. Results. A total of 92 samples were collected and 787 drug assays were performed. Tumor heterogeneity was seen in 22.4% of all cases, including 18.6% primary and 26.1% recurrent diseases (p=0.01). Two category differences (L vs. E) were seen in 4.1% primary and 11.3% recurrent cases (7.8% of all cases). Overall, tin increased frequency in EDR was seen in recurrent disease as compared to primary for all agents tested (22.9% primary vs. 31.6% recurrent, p=0.006). Marked heterogeneity of the drug resistance profiles was seen with paclitaxel as compared with cisplatin/gemcitabine (p=0.03), taxotere (p=0.04) or topotecan (p=0.04). No association was demonstrated between assay results and clinicopathologic parameters collected in this cohort. Conclusions: Treatment failure is often attributed to the development of chemoresistance. These results suggest that tumor heterogeneity may play an equally important role in treatment failure. Recurrent lesions exhibit greater heterogeneity and more frequent EDR. These data can influence therapeutic strategy i.e., multiple samples, sequential, or consolidation therapy. (C) 2005 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.