Comparative Analysis of the Monument Protection Legislation of Poland and Ukraine

被引:0
|
作者
Kharkovenko, Roman [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Natl Acad Govt Managerial Staff Culture & Arts, Hist Sci PhD Hist, Kiev, Ukraine
[2] Natl Acad Govt Managerial Staff Culture & Arts, Art Expertise Dept, Kiev, Ukraine
来源
UKRAINSKYI ISTORYCHNYI ZHURNAL | 2022年 / 03期
关键词
cultural heritage; monument protection area; cultural policy; cultural heritage monument; cultural heritage site;
D O I
10.15407/10.15407/uhj2022.03.205
中图分类号
K [历史、地理];
学科分类号
06 ;
摘要
The purpose of the study is to highlight and compare features of the monument protection legislation of Poland and Ukraine. Methodology consists in application of methods of historicism, systematicity, general scientific methods of logic, comparative analysis, specialhistorical methods (historiographical analysis, retrospective analysis, chronology, historical-systemic, historical-genetic, comparative-historical). Scientific novelty. The historical origins and factors of formation of the monument protection legislation of Poland and Ukraine, the issues of cultural policy and preservation of the national heritage are clarified. Conclusions. Having analyzed the Polish monument protection experience, in our opinion, in Ukraine it is necessary to optimize the organizational and managerial structure: transformation of the State Service for Cultural Heritage Protection of Ukraine and the State Inspectorate for Cultural Heritage of Ukraine into a functional unit of the Ministry of Culture and Information Policy of Ukraine, which will have a vertically integrated structure with structural units at regional and district administrations; further integration at the administrative level of government control in the field of cultural heritage protection; development of a system and methodology of training, retraining and advanced training of personnel for scientific, design and production activities in the field of monument protection; creation of the International Centre for Professional Development and exchange of experience in the field of cultural heritage protection; implementation of training and information programmes for this area. Thus, it can be stated that the monument protection experience of the Republic of Poland is interesting for Ukraine. This experience can be partially adopted by our state, but subject to its own national and mental characteristics. In the cultural heritage protection area of Ukraine there are enough unresolved issues and they need to be addressed. This requires the political will of the state leadership, the construction of a clear vertical of management bodies in the monument protection area, the competence of civil servants in this area and monument guards, as well as balancing the legal framework (settlement of all laws and regulations) in this area.
引用
收藏
页码:205 / 218
页数:14
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION UNDER THE LEGISLATION OF UKRAINE AND THE REPUBLIC OF POLAND: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE MAIN FEATURES
    Artemenko, O., V
    Honcharuk, L. Yu
    Kachur, V. O.
    Lytvyn, N. A.
    BULLETIN OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN, 2019, (06): : 178 - 183
  • [2] Comparative Analysis of Medical Professionals in the System of Health Protection in the Ukraine and in Poland
    Lewicka, Olga
    EKONOMISTA, 2010, (06): : 877 - 890
  • [3] Comparative analysis of business profitability in Ukraine and Poland
    Luchko, Mykhailo
    Szmitka, Stanislaw
    Dziubanovska, Nataliia
    Vovk, Iryna
    DIRECCION Y ORGANIZACION, 2024, 84 : 45 - 52
  • [4] Combating exsise Smuggling: A comparative analysis of Ukraine and Poland
    Samoilenko, Olena
    Veits, Arkadii
    Albul, Serhii
    Yankova, Liudmyla
    Shchurat, Taras
    AMAZONIA INVESTIGA, 2024, 13 (77): : 90 - 107
  • [5] Populism and Memory: Legislation of the Past in Poland, Ukraine, and Russia
    Koposov, Nikolay
    EAST EUROPEAN POLITICS AND SOCIETIES, 2022, 36 (01) : 272 - 297
  • [6] Comparative legal analysis of the anti-corruption policy in Ukraine and Poland
    Zakharova, Oleksandra
    Harasymiv, Olena
    Sosnina, Olga
    Soroka, Oleksandra
    Zaiets, Inesa
    CUESTIONES POLITICAS, 2021, 39 (69): : 91 - 114
  • [7] COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE LEVEL OF DIGITAL COMPETENCES OF FUTURE TEACHERS IN POLAND AND UKRAINE
    Rzonca, Ewelina
    INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES AND LEARNING TOOLS, 2024, 104 (06) : 81 - 95
  • [8] A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF KEY TRENDS OF PHARMACEUTICAL MARKET AND REIMBURSEMENT IN UKRAINE AND POLAND
    Zalis'ka, O.
    Brezden, O.
    Piniazhko, O.
    Vashchenko, O.
    VALUE IN HEALTH, 2018, 21 : S51 - S51
  • [9] THE FUTURE OF LOGISTICAL EDUCATION IN POLAND AND UKRAINE: COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF STUDENTS' OPINIONS
    Ryzhkova, Halina
    Pawlyszyn, Irena
    Rizun, Nina
    LOGFORUM, 2016, 12 (04) : 285 - 300
  • [10] COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF LEGISLATIONS AND MARKET ACCESS OF CANNABIS MEDICINES IN POLAND AND UKRAINE
    Brezden, O.
    Zaliska, O.
    Stostko, I
    Zaliskyy, B.
    VALUE IN HEALTH, 2023, 26 (12) : S314 - S314