Structural determinants of pharmacological specificity between D1 and D2 dopamine receptors

To test the hypothesis that pharmacological differentiation between D-1 and D-2 dopamine receptors results from interactions of selective ligands with nonconserved residues lining the binding pocket, we mutated amino acid residues in the D-2 receptor to the corresponding aligned residues in the D-1 receptor and vice versa and expressed the receptors in human embryonic kidney 293 cells. Determinations of the affinity of the 14 mutant D-2 receptors and 11 mutant D-1 receptors for D-1- and D-2-selective antagonists, and rhodopsin-based homology models of the two receptors, identified two residues whose direct interactions with certain ligands probably contribute to ligand selectivity. The D-1 receptor mutant W99(3.28)F showed dramatically increased affinity for several D-2-selective antagonists, particularly spiperone (225-fold), whereas the D-2 receptor mutant Y417(7.43)W had greatly decreased affinity for benzamide ligands such as raclopride (200-fold) and sulpiride (125-fold). The binding of the D-1-selective ligand R-(+)-7-chloro-8-hydroxy- 3-methyl-1-phenyl-2,3,4,5-tetrahydro-1H-3-benzazepine (SCH23390) was unaffected, indicating that SCH23390 makes little contact with these ancillary pocket residues. Mutation of A/V-5.39 caused modest but consistent and reciprocal changes in affinity of the receptors for D-1 and D-2-selective ligands, perhaps reflecting altered packing of the interface of helices 5 and 6. We also obtained some evidence that residues in the second extracellular loop contribute to ligand binding. We conclude that additional determinants of D-1/D-2 receptor-selective binding are located either in that loop or in the transmembrane helices but, like residue 5.39, indirectly influence the interactions of selective ligands with conserved residues by altering the shape of the primary and ancillary binding pockets.