The risk of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis is geographically determined but modifiable

被引:5
|
作者
Sharmin, Sifat [1 ,2 ]
Roos, Izanne [1 ,2 ]
Simpson-Yap, Steve [1 ,3 ,4 ]
Malpes, Charles [1 ,2 ]
Sanchez, Marina M. [1 ,2 ,5 ]
Ozakbas, Serkan [6 ]
Horakova, Dana [7 ,8 ,9 ]
Havrdova, Eva K. [7 ,8 ,9 ]
Patti, Francesco [10 ]
Alroughani, Raed [11 ]
Izquierdo, Guillermo [12 ]
Eichau, Sara [12 ]
Boz, Cavit [13 ]
Zakaria, Magd [14 ]
Onofrj, Marco [15 ]
Lugaresi, Alessandra [16 ]
Weinstock-Guttman, Bianca [17 ]
Prat, Alexandre [18 ]
Girard, Marc [18 ]
Duquette, Pierre [18 ]
Terzi, Murat [19 ]
Amato, Maria Pia [20 ]
Karabudak, Rana [21 ]
Grand'Maison, Francois [22 ]
Khoury, Samia J. [23 ]
Grammond, Pierre [24 ]
Lechner-Scott, Jeannette [25 ]
Buzzard, Katherine [26 ]
Skibina, Olga [26 ]
van der Walt, Anneke [27 ]
Butzkueven, Helmut [27 ]
Turkoglu, Recai [28 ]
Altintas, Ayse [29 ]
Maimone, Davide [30 ]
Kermode, Allan [31 ]
Shalaby, Nevin [32 ]
Pesch, Vincent V. [33 ]
Butler, Ernest [34 ]
Sidhom, Youssef [35 ]
Gouider, Riadh [36 ]
Mrabet, Saloua [36 ]
Gerlach, Oliver [37 ,38 ]
Soysal, Aysun [39 ]
Barnett, Michael [40 ]
Kuhle, Jens [41 ]
Hughes, Stella [42 ]
Sa, Maria J. [43 ]
Hodgkinson, Suzanne [44 ]
Oreja-Guevara, Celia [45 ]
Ampapa, Radek [46 ]
机构
[1] Univ Melbourne, Dept Med, CORE, Melbourne, Vic 3050, Australia
[2] Royal Melbourne Hosp, Dept Neurol, Ctr Neuroimmunol, Melbourne, Vic 3050, Australia
[3] Univ Melbourne, Melbourne Sch Populat & Global Hlth, Neuroepidemiol Unit, Melbourne, Vic 3050, Australia
[4] Univ Tasmania, Menzies Inst Med Res, Hobart, Tas 7000, Australia
[5] Hosp Germans Trias i Pujol, Dept Neurol, Badalona 08916, Spain
[6] Dokuz Eylul Univ, Fac Med, TR-35220 Konak Izmir, Turkiye
[7] Charles Univ Prague, Fac Med 1, Dept Neurol, Prague 12808, Czech Republic
[8] Charles Univ Prague, Fac Med 1, Ctr Clin Neurosci, Prague 12808, Czech Republic
[9] Gen Univ Hosp, Prague 12808, Czech Republic
[10] GF Ingrassia, Dept Med & Surg Sci & Adv Technol, I-95123 Catania, Italy
[11] Amiri Hosp, Div Neurol, Dept Med, Sharq 73767, Kuwait
[12] Hosp Univ Virgen Macarena, Multiple Sclerosis Unit, Seville 41009, Spain
[13] Karadeniz Tech Univ, Farabi Hosp, Fac Med, TR-61080 Trabzon, Turkiye
[14] Ain Shams Univ, Fac Med, Cairo 11566, Egypt
[15] Univ G DAnnunzio, Dept Neurosci Imaging & Clin Sci, I-66013 Chieti, Italy
[16] Univ Bologna, Dipartimento Sci Biomed & Neuromotorie, I-40139 Bologna, Italy
[17] SUNY Buffalo, Dept Neurol, Jacobs Multiple Sclerosis Ctr Treatment & Res, Buffalo, NY 14202 USA
[18] Univ Montreal, CHUM MS Ctr, Fac Med, Montreal, PQ H2L 4M1, Canada
[19] Mayis Univ, Fac Med, TR-55160 Samsun, Turkiye
[20] Univ Florence, Dept NEUROFARBA, I-50134 Florence, Italy
[21] Hacettepe Univ, Dept Neurol, TR-6100 Ankara, Turkiye
[22] Hop Charles LeMoyne, Neuro Rive Sud, Quebec City, PQ J4V 2J2, Canada
[23] Amer Univ Beirut Med Ctr, Nehme & Therese Tohme Multiple Sclerosis Ctr, Beirut 11072020, Lebanon
[24] CISSS Chaudiere Appalaches, Med Specialisee, Levis, ON G6X 0A1, Canada
[25] Univ Newcastle, Sch Med & Publ Hlth, Newcastle, NSW 2305, Australia
[26] Box Hill Hosp, Dept Neurol, Melbourne, Vic 3128, Australia
[27] Alfred Hosp, Dept Neurol, Melbourne, Vic 3000, Australia
[28] Haydarpasa Numune Training & Res Hosp, Dept Neurol, TR-34668 Istanbul, Turkiye
[29] Koc Univ, Res Ctr Translat Med KUTTAM, Sch Med, Dept Neurol, TR-34450 Istanbul, Turkiye
[30] UOC Neurol, Ctr Sclerosi Multipla, ARNAS Garibaldi, I-95124 Catania, Italy
[31] Univ Western Australia, Perron Inst, Nedlands, WA 6009, Australia
[32] Kasr Ainy MS Res Unit KAMSU, Dept Neurol, Cairo 11562, Egypt
[33] Clin Univ St Luc, Serv Neurol, B-1200 XL Brussels, Belgium
[34] Monash Med Ctr, Melbourne, Vic 3168, Australia
[35] Razi Hosp, Dept Neurol, Manouba 2010, Tunisia
[36] Univ Tunis El Manar, Clin Invest Ctr Neurosci & Mental Hlth, Fac Med, Tunis 1068, Tunisia
[37] Acad MS Ctr Zuyderland, Dept Neurol, Zuyderland Med Ctr, NL-5500 Sittard Geleen, Netherlands
[38] Maastricht Univ Med Ctr, Sch Mental Hlth & Neurosci, Dept Neurol, NL-6131 Maastricht, Netherlands
[39] Bakirkoy Educ & Res Hosp Psychiat & Neurol Dis, Dept Neurol, TR-34147 Istanbul, Turkiye
[40] Brain & Mind Ctr, Multiple Sclerosis Clin, Sydney, NSW 2050, Australia
[41] Univ Hosp & Univ Basel, Dept Med & Clin Res, Neurol Clin & Policlin, CH-4000 Basel, Switzerland
[42] Royal Victoria Hosp, Dept Neurol, Belfast BT12 6BA, Antrim, North Ireland
[43] Ctr Hosp Univ Sao Joao, Dept Neurol, P-4200319 Porto, Portugal
[44] Univ New South Wales, Immune Tolerance Laboratory Ingham Inst, Sydney, NSW 2170, Australia
[45] Hosp Clin San Carlos, Dept Neurol, Madrid 28050, Spain
[46] Nemocnice Jihlava, MS Centrum, Jihlava 58633, Czech Republic
[47] Aarhus Univ Hosp, Dept Neurol, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
[48] Hosp Germans Trias i Pujol, Dept Neurol, Badalona 8916, Spain
[49] Azienda Osped Rilievo Nazl San Giuseppe Moscati, Ctr Sclerosi Multipla, I-83100 Avellino, Italy
[50] Univ Queensland, Royal Brisbane & Womens Hosp, Brisbane, Qld 4000, Australia
关键词
secondary progressive multiple sclerosis; disease-modifying therapy; latitude; geography; health expenditure; LONG-TERM EVOLUTION; DISABILITY; PHASE; ONSET;
D O I
10.1093/brain/awad218
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Geographical variations in the incidence and prevalence of multiple sclerosis have been reported globally. Latitude as a surrogate for exposure to ultraviolet radiation but also other lifestyle and environmental factors are regarded as drivers of this variation. No previous studies evaluated geographical variation in the risk of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis, an advanced form of multiple sclerosis that is characterized by steady accrual of irreversible disability.We evaluated differences in the risk of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis in relation to latitude and country of residence, modified by high-to-moderate efficacy immunotherapy in a geographically diverse cohort of patients with relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis. The study included relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis patients from the global MSBase registry with at least one recorded assessment of disability. Secondary progressive multiple sclerosis was identified as per clinician diagnosis. Sensitivity analyses used the operationalized definition of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis and the Swedish decision tree algorithm. A proportional hazards model was used to estimate the cumulative risk of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis by country of residence (latitude), adjusted for sex, age at disease onset, time from onset to relapsing-remitting phase, disability (Multiple Sclerosis Severity Score) and relapse activity at study inclusion, national multiple sclerosis prevalence, government health expenditure, and proportion of time treated with high-to-moderate efficacy disease-modifying therapy. Geographical variation in time from relapsing-remitting phase to secondary progressive phase of multiple sclerosis was modelled through a proportional hazards model with spatially correlated frailties.We included 51 126 patients (72% female) from 27 countries. The median survival time from relapsing-remitting phase to secondary progressive multiple sclerosis among all patients was 39 (95% confidence interval: 37 to 43) years. Higher latitude [median hazard ratio = 1.21, 95% credible interval (1.16, 1.26)], higher national multiple sclerosis prevalence [1.07 (1.03, 1.11)], male sex [1.30 (1.22, 1.39)], older age at onset [1.35 (1.30, 1.39)], higher disability [2.40 (2.34, 2.47)] and frequent relapses [1.18 (1.15, 1.21)] at inclusion were associated with increased hazard of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis. Higher proportion of time on high-to-moderate efficacy therapy substantially reduced the hazard of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis [0.76 (0.73, 0.79)] and reduced the effect of latitude [interaction: 0.95 (0.92, 0.99)]. At the country-level, patients in Oman, Tunisia, Iran and Canada had higher risks of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis relative to the other studied regions.Higher latitude of residence is associated with a higher probability of developing secondary progressive multiple sclerosis. High-to-moderate efficacy immunotherapy can mitigate some of this geographically co-determined risk. By analysing longitudinal data from 27 countries, Sharmin et al. reveal a geographically varying risk of conversion to secondary progressive disease in patients with multiple sclerosis. Higher latitude of residence increases the risk while high-to-moderate efficacy immunotherapies reduce the risk substantially.
引用
收藏
页码:4633 / 4644
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] The risk of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis is geographically determined but modifiable
    Sharmin, Sifat
    Roos, Izanne
    Simpson-Yap, Steve
    Malpas, Charles
    Lechner-Scott, Jeannette
    Buzzard, Katherine
    Skibina, Olga
    van der Walt, Anneke
    Butzkueven, Helmut
    Kermode, Allan
    Butler, Ernest
    Barnett, Michael
    Hodgkinson, Suzanne
    McCombe, Pamela
    Taylor, Bruce
    Slee, Mark
    Macdonell, Richard
    Garber, Justin
    Shaw, Cameron
    Shuey, Neil
    Massey, Jennifer
    Hardy, Todd
    Parratt, John
    Kalincik, Tomas
    MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS JOURNAL, 2024, 30 (04) : 6 - 6
  • [2] The risk of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis is geographically determined but modifiable
    Sharmin, S.
    Roos, I.
    Simpson-Yap, S.
    Malpas, C.
    Sanchez, M. Martinez
    Ozakbas, S.
    Horakova, D.
    Havrdova, E. K.
    Patti, F.
    Alroughani, R.
    Shaygannejad, V.
    Izquierdo, G.
    Eichau, S.
    Boz, C.
    Zakaria, M.
    Onofrj, M.
    Lugaresi, A.
    Weinstock-Guttman, B.
    Prat, A.
    Girard, M.
    Duquette, P.
    Terzi, M.
    Amato, M. P.
    Karabudak, R.
    Grand'Maison, F.
    Yamout, B.
    Khoury, S. J.
    Grammond, P.
    Lechner-Scott, J.
    Buzzard, K.
    Skibina, O.
    Van der Walt, A.
    Butzkueven, H.
    Turkoglu, R.
    Altintas, A.
    Blanco, Y.
    Maimone, D.
    Kermode, A.
    Shalaby, N.
    Van Pesch, V.
    Butler, E.
    Sidhom, Y.
    Gouider, R.
    Gerlach, O.
    Soysal, A.
    Barnett, M.
    Kuhle, J.
    Hughes, S.
    Sa, M. Jose
    Kalincik, T.
    MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS JOURNAL, 2022, 28 (3_SUPPL) : 967 - 970
  • [3] Risk factors for secondary progressive multiple sclerosis
    Gruszka, E.
    Pokryszko-Dragan, A.
    Dubik-Jezierzanska, M.
    Bilinska, M.
    MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS, 2006, 12 : S161 - S161
  • [4] Risk of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis: a longitudinal study
    Fambiatos, A.
    Jokubaitis, V.
    Spelman, T.
    Horakova, D.
    Havrdova, E.
    Trojano, M.
    Prat, A.
    Girard, M.
    Duquette, P.
    Lugaresi, A.
    Izquierdo, G.
    Grand'Maison, F.
    Grammond, P.
    Sola, P.
    Ferraro, D.
    Alroughani, R.
    Terzi, M.
    Hupperts, R.
    Boz, C.
    Lechner-Scott, J.
    Pucci, E.
    Bergamaschi, R.
    Van Pesch, V.
    Ozakbas, S.
    Granella, F.
    Ramo, C.
    Turkoglu, R.
    Iuliano, G.
    Spitaleri, D.
    McCombe, P.
    Solaro, C.
    Slee, M.
    Fernandez-Bolanos, R.
    Ampapa, R.
    Soysal, A.
    Petersen, T.
    Sanchez-Menoyo, J. L.
    Verheul, F.
    Prevost, J.
    Sidhom, Y.
    Gouider, R.
    Van Wijmeersch, B.
    Vucic, S.
    Cristiano, E.
    Saladino, M. L.
    Deri, N.
    Barnett, M.
    van der Walt, A.
    Butzkueven, H.
    Kalincik, T.
    MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS JOURNAL, 2017, 23 : 109 - 112
  • [5] Risk of secondary progressive multiple sclerosis: A longitudinal study
    Fambiatos, Adam
    Jokubaitis, Vilija
    Horakova, Dana
    Havrdova, Eva Kubala
    Trojano, Maria
    Prat, Alexandre
    Girard, Marc
    Duquette, Pierre
    Lugaresi, Alessandra
    Izquierdo, Guillermo
    Grand'Maison, Francois
    Grammond, Pierre
    Sola, Patrizia
    Ferraro, Diana
    Alroughani, Raed
    Terzi, Murat
    Hupperts, Raymond
    Boz, Cavit
    Lechner-Scott, Jeannette
    Pucci, Eugenio
    Bergamaschi, Roberto
    Van Pesch, Vincent
    Ozakbas, Serkan
    Granella, Franco
    Turkoglu, Recai
    Iuliano, Gerardo
    Spitaleri, Daniele
    McCombe, Pamela
    Solaro, Claudio
    Slee, Mark
    Ampapa, Radek
    Soysal, Aysun
    Petersen, Thor
    Sanchez-Menoyo, Jose Luis
    Verheul, Freek
    Prevost, Julie
    Sidhom, Youssef
    Van Wijmeersch, Bart
    Vucic, Steve
    Cristiano, Edgardo
    Saladino, Maria Laura
    Deri, Norma
    Barnett, Michael
    Olascoaga, Javier
    Moore, Fraser
    Skibina, Olga
    Gray, Orla
    Fragoso, Yara
    Yamout, Bassem
    Shaw, Cameron
    MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS JOURNAL, 2020, 26 (01) : 79 - 90
  • [6] Risk of transition to secondary progressive multiple sclerosis and accumulation of disability in progressive multiple sclerosis are not influenced by current therapies
    Alcala, C.
    Gascon, F.
    Perez-Miralles, F-C.
    Escutia, M.
    Coret, F.
    Casanova, B.
    MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS JOURNAL, 2017, 23 : 702 - 702
  • [7] Factors determining the risk of conversion to secondary progressive multiple sclerosis
    Tedeholm, H.
    Skoog, B.
    Runmarker, B.
    Oden, A.
    Andersen, O.
    MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS JOURNAL, 2013, 19 (11) : 358 - 358
  • [8] Siponimod in secondary progressive multiple sclerosis
    Rissardo, Jamir Pitton
    Caprara, Ana Leticia Fornari
    INTERNATIONAL ARCHIVES OF HEALTH SCIENCES, 2020, 7 (03) : 155 - 155
  • [9] Natalizumab in secondary progressive multiple sclerosis
    Edan, Gilles
    LANCET NEUROLOGY, 2018, 17 (05): : 384 - 385
  • [10] Defining secondary progressive multiple sclerosis
    Lorscheider, J.
    Buzzard, K.
    Jokubaitis, V.
    Spelman, T.
    Havrdova, E.
    Horakova, D.
    Trojano, M.
    Izquierdo, G.
    Girard, M.
    Duquette, P.
    Prat, A.
    Lugaresi, A.
    Grand'Maison, F.
    Grammond, P.
    Hupperts, R.
    Alroughani, R.
    Sola, P.
    Boz, C.
    Terzi, M.
    Pucci, E.
    Lechner-Scott, J.
    Bergamaschi, R.
    Oreja-Guevara, C.
    Iuliano, G.
    Van Pesch, V.
    Bolanos, R. Fernandez
    Granella, F.
    Rio, M. E.
    Ramo, C.
    Spitaleri, D. L.
    Petersen, T.
    Slee, M.
    Verheul, F.
    Ampapa, R.
    Amato, M. P.
    McCombe, P.
    Vucic, S.
    Sanchez Menoyo, J. L.
    Cristiano, E.
    Barnett, M.
    Hodgkinson, S.
    Cabrera-Gomez, J. A.
    Olascoaga, J.
    Saladino, M. L.
    Flechter, S.
    Gray, O.
    Deri, N.
    Butzkueven, H.
    Kalincik, T.
    MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS JOURNAL, 2015, 21 : 798 - 800