Consent for trainee participation in abortion care: A qualitative study of patient experiences and preferences in the United States

被引:1
|
作者
Crystal-Ornelas, Lara [1 ,2 ]
Sarnaik, Shashi [1 ]
Dianat, Shokoufeh [2 ]
Dehlendorf, Christine [1 ]
Holt, Kelsey [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Calif San Francisco, Dept Family & Community Med, San Francisco, CA 94143 USA
[2] Collect Energy Nurturing Training Reprod & Sexual, Lynchburg, VA 24502 USA
关键词
Abortion care; Abortion training; Autonomy; Coercion; Informed consent; Medical education; PELVIC EXAMINATIONS; MEDICAL-STUDENTS; ANESTHESIA;
D O I
10.1016/j.contraception.2023.109974
中图分类号
R71 [妇产科学];
学科分类号
100211 ;
摘要
Objectives: Abortion training for clinicians is crucial to ensure patients' future access to full-spectrum re-productive healthcare. Given the complex sociopolitical context of abortion, consent to allow a trainee's involvement in abortion care requires careful attention to avoid harm to patients while also ensuring adequate clinician training for the future provision of care. In order to inform the development of patient -centered recommendations, we assessed patient experiences and preferences around consent for trainee participation during abortion care.Study design: We interviewed participants who received abortion care at sites with medical trainees in the United States. We conducted interviews via zoom (video-off) between August 2021 and January 2022. We audio-recorded and transcribed the interviews. We coded transcripts using NVivo software and analyzed inductively using thematic analysis.Results: Twenty-four (n = 24) participants reflected a diverse range of sociodemographics as well as location of abortion service. Some reported experiences of coercion related to trainee involvement, ranging from subtle to overt. Participants preferred consent for trainee involvement in abortion care be a process outside the procedure room, while clothed, without the trainer or trainee present to allow for time to consider options without pressure to say yes.Conclusions: Patient-centered approaches to seeking consent for trainee involvement in abortion care must reduce potential for coercion. A standardized consent before the procedure room by a trained staff member without the trainer or trainee present can help prioritize patient autonomy. Understanding care team member roles and upholding confidentiality and privacy are paramount to patients feeling safe with trai-nees present.Implications: Our finding that patients experience varying levels of coercion to allow trainee participation in their abortion care highlights the dire need for patient-centered systemic changes-such as ensuring that consent take place outside the procedure room in a scripted fashion at eye level, while patients are clothed, and without trainers/trainees present-to maintain patient autonomy.(c) 2023 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Inc. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
引用
收藏
页数:6
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Patient preferences and experiences of participation in surgical cancer care
    Drott, Jenny
    Fomichov, Victoria
    Norden, Maria
    Larsson, Anna Lindhoff
    Sandstrom, Per
    Bjornsson, Bergthor
    Eldh, Ann Catrine
    WORLDVIEWS ON EVIDENCE-BASED NURSING, 2022, 19 (05) : 405 - 414
  • [2] Determinants of patient participation for safer care: A qualitative study of physicians' experiences and perceptions
    Schildmeijer, Kristina
    Nilsen, Per
    Ericsson, Carin
    Brostrom, Anders
    Skagerstrom, Janna
    HEALTH SCIENCE REPORTS, 2018, 1 (10)
  • [3] Person-centered, high-quality care from a distance: A qualitative study of patient experiences of TelAbortion, a model for direct-to-patient medication abortion by mail in the United States
    Kerestes, Courtney
    Delafield, Rebecca
    Elia, Jennifer
    Shochet, Tara
    Kaneshiro, Bliss
    Soon, Reni
    PERSPECTIVES ON SEXUAL AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH, 2022, 54 (04) : 177 - 187
  • [4] Patient participation: A qualitative study of immigrant women and their experiences
    Bramberg, Elisabeth Bjork
    Nystrom, Maria
    Dahlberg, Karin
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF QUALITATIVE STUDIES ON HEALTH AND WELL-BEING, 2010, 5 (01)
  • [5] Abortion experiences and preferences of transgender, nonbinary, and gender-expansive people in the United States
    Moseson, Heidi
    Fix, Laura
    Ragosta, Sachiko
    Forsberg, Hannah
    Hastings, Jen
    Stoeff, Ari
    Lunn, Mitchell R.
    Flentje, Annesa
    Capriotti, Matthew R.
    Lubensky, Micah E.
    Obedin-Maliver, Juno
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF OBSTETRICS AND GYNECOLOGY, 2021, 224 (04) : 376.e1 - 376.e11
  • [6] Brazilian Immigrant Womens Perspectives and Experiences of Health Care in the United States: A Qualitative Study
    Lindsay, Ana
    de Oliveira, Mariana Goncalves
    Machado, Marcia Maria Tavares
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF QUALITATIVE METHODS, 2016, 15 (01):
  • [7] Informed or Misinformed Consent? Abortion Policy in the United States
    Bullock, Holly
    OBSTETRICS AND GYNECOLOGY, 2016, 128 (04): : 907 - 907
  • [8] Informed or Misinformed Consent? Abortion Policy in the United States
    Daniels, Cynthia R.
    Ferguson, Janna
    Howard, Grace
    Roberti, Amanda
    JOURNAL OF HEALTH POLITICS POLICY AND LAW, 2016, 41 (02) : 181 - 209
  • [9] Patient Preferences and Experiences in Hyperemesis Gravidarum Treatment: A Qualitative Study
    van Vliet, Relin
    Bink, Marieke
    Polman, Julian
    Suntharan, Amaran
    Grooten, Iris
    Zwolsman, Sandra E.
    Roseboom, Tessa J.
    Painter, Rebecca C.
    JOURNAL OF PREGNANCY, 2018, 2018
  • [10] Training surgeons and the informed consent discussion in paediatric patients: a qualitative study examining trainee participation disclosure
    Bhanot, Kunal
    Chang, Justin
    Grant, Samuel
    Fecteau, Annie
    Camp, Mark
    BMJ OPEN QUALITY, 2019, 8 (03)