Should time-lag and time-accumulation effects of climate be considered in attribution of vegetation dynamics? Case study of China's temperate grassland region

Although the time-lag and time-accumulation effects (TLTAEs) of climatic factors on vegetation growth have been investigated extensively, the uncertainties caused by disregarding TLTAEs in the attribution analysis of long-term changes in vegetation remain unclear. This hinders our understanding of the associated changes in ecosystems and the effects of climate change. In this study, using multiple methods, we evaluate the biases of attribution analyses of vegetation dynamics caused by the non-consideration of TLTAEs in the temperate grassland region (TGR) of China from 2000 to 2019. Based on the datasets of the normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI), temperature (TMP), precipitation (PRE), and solar radiation (SR), the temporal reaction patterns of vegetation are analyzed, and the relationships among these variables under two scenarios (considering and disregarding TLTAEs) are compared. The results indicate that most areas of the TGR show a greening trend. A time-lag or time-accumulation effect of the three climatic variables is observed in most areas with significant spatial differences. The lagged times of the vegetation response to PRE are particularly prominent, with an average of 2.12 months in the TGR. When the TLTAE is considered, the areas where changes in the NDVI are affected by climatic factors expanded significantly, whereas the explanatory power of climate change on NDVI change increased by an average of 9.3% in the TGR; these improvements are more prominent in relatively arid areas. This study highlights the importance of including TLTAEs in the attribution of vegetation dynamics and the assessment of climatic effects on ecosystems.