On defining 'fundamentalism'

被引:5
|
作者
Peels, Rik [1 ]
机构
[1] Vrije Univ Amsterdam, Fac Humanities, Fac Relig & Theol, Philosophy Dept,Dept Beliefs & Pratices, NL-1081 HV Amsterdam, Netherlands
基金
欧洲研究理事会;
关键词
definition; family resemblance; fundamentalism; necessary and sufficient conditions; operationalization;
D O I
10.1017/S0034412522000683
中图分类号
B9 [宗教];
学科分类号
010107 ;
摘要
This article combines two things: it explores how one should undertake the project of defining 'fundamentalism' and, based on the ensuing desiderata, it actually provides such a definition. After a few preliminary comments on 'fundamentalism' and the value of defining it, five goals of definitions are distinguished and elucidated: accuracy, precision, fairness, clarity, and fecundity. After that, various kinds of definitions and their interrelations are spelled out. Finally, the author provides and defends a so-called explicative definition of 'fundamentalism' both in terms of necessary and sufficient conditions and in terms of stereotypical properties. On the basis of empirical literature and a scoping review, it is argued that a movement is fundamentalist if and only if it is (i) reactionary towards modern developments, (ii) itself modern, and (iii) based on a grand historical narrative. More specifically, a movement is fundamentalist if it exemplifies a large number of the following properties: (i) it is reactionary in its rejection of liberal ethics, science, or technological exploitation; (ii) it is modern in seeking certainty and control, embracing literalism and infallibility about particular scriptures, actively using media and technology, or making universal claims; and (iii) it presents a grand historical narrative in terms of paradise, fall, and redemption, or cosmic dualism.
引用
收藏
页码:729 / 747
页数:19
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [2] Atheist Fundamentalism against Religious Fundamentalism
    Paine, Scott
    HORIZONTE-REVISTA DE ESTUDOS DE TEOLOGIA E CIENCIAS DA RELIGIAO, 2010, 8 (18): : 9 - 26
  • [3] FUNDAMENTALISM
    VOLPINTESTA, EJ
    HOSPITAL PRACTICE, 1983, 18 (10): : 20 - &
  • [4] For Fundamentalism
    Hoefer, Carl
    NANCY CARTWRIGHT'S PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 2008, : 307 - 321
  • [5] Fundamentalism
    Shaw, E
    RELIGION, 2003, 33 (04) : 387 - 389
  • [6] For fundamentalism
    Hoefer, C
    PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 2003, 70 (05) : 1401 - 1412
  • [7] A NEW FACE OF FUNDAMENTALISM Q-FUNDAMENTALISM
    Czornik, Katarzyna
    Szynol, Monika
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF SCIENCE AND THEOLOGY, 2023, 19 (03) : 19 - 34
  • [8] FUNDAMENTALISM
    HYAMS, AS
    COMMENTARY, 1985, 80 (02) : 14 - 14
  • [9] Fundamentalism
    Robertson, Robin
    PSYCHOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES-A QUARTERLY JOURNAL OF JUNGIAN THOUGHT, 2009, 52 (04): : 409 - 410
  • [10] Fundamentalism
    Appleby, RS
    Marty, ME
    FOREIGN POLICY, 2002, (128) : 16 - +