A Barrier for Further Approximating Sorting by Transpositions

The transposition distance problem is a classical problem in genome rearrangements, which seeks to determine the minimum number of transpositions needed to transform a linear chromosome into another represented by the permutations pi and sigma, respectively. This article focuses on the equivalent problem of sorting by transpositions (SBT), where sigma is the identity permutation iota. Specifically, we investigate palisades, a family of permutations that are "hard" to sort, as they require numerous transpositions above the celebrated lower bound devised by Bafna and Pevzner. By determining the transposition distance of palisades, we were able to provide the exact transposition diameter for 3-permutations (TD3), a special subset of the symmetric group Sn, essential for the study of approximate solutions for SBT using the simplification technique. The exact value for TD3 has remained unknown since Elias and Hartman showed an upper bound for it. Another consequence of determining the transposition distance of palisades is that, using as lower bound the one by Bafna and Pevzner, it is impossible to guarantee approximation ratios lower than 1.375 when approximating SBT. This finding has significant implications for the study of SBT, as this problem has been the subject of intense research efforts for the past 25 years.