ENSO Disrupts Boreal Winter CRE Feedback

Twenty years of satellite-based cloud and radiation observations allow us to examine the observed cloud ra-diative effect (CRE) feedback (i.e., CRE change per unit change in global mean surface temperature). By employing a de-composition method to separate the contribution of "internal changes" and "relative-frequency-of-occurrence (RFO) changes" of distinct cloud regime (CR) groups, notable seasonal contrasts of CRE feedback characteristics emerge. Boreal winter CRE feedback is dominated by the positive shortwave CRE (SWCRE) feedback of oceanic low-thick clouds, due to their decreasing RFO as temperature rises. This signal is most likely due to El Nino-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) activ-ity. When ENSO signals are excluded, boreal winter CRE feedback becomes qualitatively similar to the boreal summer feedback, where several CR groups contribute to the total CRE feedback more evenly. Most CR groups' CRE feedbacks largely come from changing RFO (e.g., the predominant transition from oceanic cumulus to broken clouds and more oc-currences of higher convective clouds with warming temperature). At the same time, low-thick and broken clouds experi-ence optical thinning and decreasing cloud fraction, and these features are more prominent in boreal summer than winter. Overall, the seasonally asymmetric patterns of CRE feedback, primarily due to ENSO, introduce complexity in assess-ments of CRE feedback.