Comment to the paper "Quantum mechanical effects for a hydrogen atom confined in a dielectric spherical microcavity"

被引：0
|
作者：
Martinez-Sanchez, Michael-Adan [1 ]
Vargas, Rubicelia [1 ]
Garza, Jorge [1 ]
机构：
[1] Univ Autonoma Metropolitana Iztapalapa, Dept Quim, Div Ciencias Bas Ingn, San Rafael Atlixco 186,Col Vicentina, Mexico City 09340, Mexico
来源：
CHEMICAL PHYSICS | 2023年 / 574卷
关键词：
Confinement; Rigid walls; Shannon entropy; Hydrogen atom;
D O I：
10.1016/j.chemphys.2023.112040
中图分类号：
O64 [物理化学（理论化学）、化学物理学];
学科分类号：
070304 ; 081704 ;
摘要：
The article "Quantum mechanical effects for a hydrogen atom confined in a dielectric spherical microcavity"(Wang et al., 2022) does not describe correctly the Shannon entropy for the states 3p and 4p for the hydrogen atom confined by a dielectric spherical microcavity. In this comment, we show the correct behavior for these states and conclude that there was an error in the data found by the authors of that article. Thus, looking for a physical meaning for the behavior observed in that paper makes no sense.
引用
收藏
页数：2
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Quantum mechanical effects for a hydrogen atom confined in a dielectric spherical microcavity
    Wang, De-hua
    Zhang, Jie
    Sun, Zhao-peng
    Zhang, Shu-fang
    Zhao, Gang
    CHEMICAL PHYSICS, 2021, 551
  • [2] Confined quantum systems: The parabolically confined hydrogen atom
    Krahmer, DS
    Schleich, WP
    Yakovlev, VP
    JOURNAL OF PHYSICS A-MATHEMATICAL AND GENERAL, 1998, 31 (19): : 4493 - 4520
  • [3] Anomalous Stark effect in the ground state of the confined hydrogen atom in a spherical quantum dot
    Sahoo, S
    Ho, YK
    PHYSICAL REVIEW B, 2004, 69 (16) : 165323 - 1
  • [4] Quantum topology and computer simulation of confined hydrogen atom inside spherical-form gap
    Beznosyuk, SA
    Mezentsev, DA
    Zhukovsky, MS
    Zhukovsky, TM
    HYDROGEN MATERIALS SCIENCE AND CHEMISTRY OF CARBON NANOMATERIALS, 2004, 172 : 531 - 538
  • [5] Internal disorder of hydrogenic-like atom trapped in dielectric spherical microcavity
    Liu, Xue
    Wang, De-Hua
    ACTA PHYSICA SINICA, 2023, 72 (10)
  • [6] QUANTUM STATES OF A CONFINED OR HALF-CONFINED HYDROGEN-ATOM
    YANG, C
    WANG, BI
    CHINESE JOURNAL OF PHYSICS, 1993, 31 (04) : 481 - 496
  • [7] Effects of an electric field on the confined hydrogen impurity states in a spherical parabolic quantum dot
    He, Lili
    Xie, Wenfang
    SUPERLATTICES AND MICROSTRUCTURES, 2010, 47 (02) : 266 - 273
  • [8] A hydrogen-like atom confined within an impenetrable spherical box
    Laughlin, C
    Burrows, BL
    Cohen, M
    JOURNAL OF PHYSICS B-ATOMIC MOLECULAR AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, 2002, 35 (03) : 701 - 715
  • [9] QUANTUM SIZE EFFECTS OF HYDROGEN IMPURITY AT OFF-CENTER DONOR ATOM IN SPHERICAL QUANTUM DOTS
    Huang, Yung Sheng
    Huang, Jung Sheng
    Lee, Kuan Wei
    Chang, Fang-Ling
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MODERN PHYSICS B, 2009, 23 (05): : 639 - 650
  • [10] The hydrogen atom confined in both Debye screening potential and impenetrable spherical box
    Kang, Shuai
    Yang, You-Chang
    He, Juan
    Xiong, Fei-Qiao
    Xu, Ning
    CENTRAL EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICS, 2013, 11 (05): : 584 - 593
12345