What Is a Housing Shortage?

The United States has faced decades of increasing housing costs and declining construction. Many scholars and policymakers argue that additional supply is necessary to combat inadequate availability. In their analysis, however, McClure and Schwartz argue that the nation faces no housing shortage except for extremely low-income renters, which they propose be addressed by leveraging the existing stock. I argue instead for a continued emphasis on increasing supply as a mechanism to improve housing conditions. I show, first, that additional housing stock is associated with more units per additional resident in an area. Second, I demonstrate that increasing supply is positively associated with lower housing cost growth, though other issues, like household income growth, are likely more important variables in explaining affordability. Finally, I contest the authors' use of metropolitan geographies as the primary level for examining housing affordability, given the nation's history of segregation and variation in access to opportunity.