RETRACTED: Eye tracking: empirical foundations for a minimal reporting guideline (Retracted Article)

被引：119

作者：

Holmqvist, Kenneth ^{[1
,2
,3
]}

Oerbom, Saga Lee ^{[3
]}

Hooge, Ignace T. C. ^{[4
]}

Niehorster, Diederick C. ^{[5
,6
]}

Alexander, Robert G. ^{[7
]}

Andersson, Richard ^{[8
]}

Benjamins, Jeroen S. ^{[4
,9
]}

Blignaut, Pieter ^{[2
]}

Brouwer, Anne-Marie ^{[10
]}

Chuang, Lewis L. ^{[11
,12
]}

Dalrymple, Kirsten A. ^{[13
]}

Drieghe, Denis ^{[14
]}

Dunn, Matt J. ^{[15
]}

Ettinger, Ulrich ^{[16
]}

Fiedler, Susann ^{[17
]}

Foulsham, Tom ^{[18
]}

van der Geest, Jos N. ^{[19
]}

Hansen, Dan Witzner ^{[20
]}

Hutton, Samuel B. ^{[21
]}

Kasneci, Enkelejda ^{[22
]}

Kingstone, Alan ^{[23
]}

Knox, Paul C. ^{[24
]}

Kok, Ellen M. ^{[25
,26
]}

Lee, Helena ^{[27
]}

Lee, Joy Yeonjoo ^{[28
]}

Leppanen, Jukka M. ^{[29
]}

Macknik, Stephen ^{[7
]}

Majaranta, Paivi ^{[30
]}

Martinez-Conde, Susana ^{[7
]}

Nuthmann, Antje ^{[31
]}

Nystrom, Marcus ^{[5
]}

Orquin, Jacob L. ^{[32
,33
]}

Otero-Millan, Jorge ^{[34
]}

Park, Soon Young ^{[35
]}

Popelka, Stanislav ^{[36
]}

Proudlock, Frank ^{[37
]}

Renkewitz, Frank ^{[38
]}

Roorda, Austin ^{[34
]}

Schulte-Mecklenbeck, Michael ^{[39
,40
]}

Sharif, Bonita ^{[41
]}

Shic, Frederick ^{[42
,43
]}

Shovman, Mark ^{[44
,45
]}

Thomas, Mervyn G. ^{[37
]}

Venrooij, Ward ^{[46
]}

Zemblys, Raimondas ^{[47
]}

Hessels, Roy S. ^{[4
]}

机构：

[1] Nicolaus Copernicus Univ, Dept Psychol, Torun, Poland

[2] Univ Free State, Dept Comp Sci & Informat, Bloemfontein, South Africa

[3] Regensburg Univ, Dept Psychol, Regensburg, Germany

[4] Univ Utrecht, Helmholtz Inst, Expt Psychol, Utrecht, Netherlands

[5] Lund Univ, Lund Univ Humanities Lab, Lund, Sweden

[6] Lund Univ, Dept Psychol, Lund, Sweden

[7] SUNY Downstate Hlth Sci Univ, Dept Ophthalmol, Brooklyn, NY USA

[8] Tobii Pro AB, Danderyd, Sweden

[9] Univ Utrecht, Social Hlth & Org Psychol, Utrecht, Netherlands

[10] TNO, Soesterberg, Netherlands

[11] Leibniz Inst Working Environm & Human Factors, Dept Ergon, Dortmund, Germany

[12] Ludwig Maximilians Univ Munchen, Inst Informat, Munich, Germany

[13] Univ Minnesota, Inst Child Dev, 51 E River Rd, Minneapolis, MN 55455 USA

[14] Univ Southampton, Sch Psychol, Southampton, Hants, England

[15] Cardiff Univ, Sch Optometry & Vis Sci, Cardiff, Wales

[16] Univ Bonn, Dept Psychol, Bonn, Germany

[17] Vienna Univ Econ & Business, Vienna, Austria

[18] Univ Essex, Dept Psychol, Colchester, Essex, England

[19] Erasmus MC, Dept Neurosci, Rotterdam, Netherlands

[20] IT Univ Copenhagen, Dept Comp Sci, Machine Learning Grp, Copenhagen, Denmark

[21] SR Res Ltd, Ottawa, ON, Canada

[22] Univ Tubingen, Human Comp Interact, Tubingen, Germany

[23] Univ British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada

[24] Univ Liverpool, Inst Life Course & Med Sci, Dept Eye & Vis Sci, Liverpool, Merseyside, England

[25] Univ Utrecht, Fac Social & Behav Sci, Dept Educ & Pedag, Div Educ, Utrecht, Netherlands

[26] Open Univ Netherlands, Fac Educ Sci, Dept Online Learning & Instruct, Heerlen, Netherlands

[27] Univ Southampton, Southampton, Hants, England

[28] Maastricht Univ, Fac Hlth Med & Life Sci, Sch Hlth Profess Educ, Maastricht, Netherlands

[29] Univ Turku, Dept Psychol & Speed Language Pathol, Turku, Finland

[30] Tampere Univ, Fac Informat Technol & Commun Sci, TAUCHI Res Ctr, Comp Sci, Tampere, Finland

[31] Univ Kiel, Inst Psychol, Kiel, Germany

[32] Aarhus Univ, Dept Management, Aarhus, Denmark

[33] Reykjavik Univ, Ctr Res Mkt & Consumer Psychol, Reykjavik, Iceland

[34] Univ Calif Berkeley, Herbert Wertheim Sch Optometry & Vis Sci, Berkeley, CA 94720 USA

[35] Med Univ Vienna, Univ Vet Med Vienna, Messerli Res Inst, Comparat Cognit, Vienna, Austria

[36] Palacky Univ Olomouc, Dept Geoinformat, Olomouc, Czech Republic

[37] Univ Leicester, Univ Leicester Ulverscroft Eye Unit, Dept Neurosci Psychol & Behav, Leicester, Leics, England

[38] Univ Erfurt, Dept Psychol, Erfurt, Germany

[39] Univ Bern, Bern, Switzerland

[40] Max Planck Inst Human Dev, Berlin, Germany

[41] Univ Nebraska, Sch Comp, Lincoln, NE USA

[42] Seattle Childrens Res Inst, Ctr Child Hlth Behav & Dev, Seattle, WA USA

[43] Univ Washington, Sch Med, Dept Gen Pediat, Seattle, WA USA

[44] Eyeviat Syst, Herzliyya, Israel

[45] Bezalel Acad Arts & Design, Dept Ind Design, Jerusalem, Israel

[46] Univ Twente, Elect Engn Math & Comp Sci EEMCS, Enschede, Netherlands

[47] Smart Eye AB, Gothenburg, Sweden

来源：

BEHAVIOR RESEARCH METHODS | 2023年 / 55卷 / 01期

关键词：

Eye movements; Eye tracking; Data quality; Reporting guidelines; Reporting standards; Reporting practices; Replicability; Reproducibility; SCLERAL SEARCH COIL; POST-SACCADIC OSCILLATIONS; PUPIL SIZE; SMOOTH-PURSUIT; VISUAL-ATTENTION; GAZE BEHAVIOR; TIME-COURSE; BINOCULAR COORDINATION; INDIVIDUAL-DIFFERENCES; FIXATION DURATION;

D O I：

10.3758/s13428-021-01762-8

中图分类号：

B841 [心理学研究方法];

学科分类号：

040201 ;

摘要：

In this paper, we present a review of how the various aspects of any study using an eye tracker (such as the instrument, methodology, environment, participant, etc.) affect the quality of the recorded eye-tracking data and the obtained eye-movement and gaze measures. We take this review to represent the empirical foundation for reporting guidelines of any study involving an eye tracker. We compare this empirical foundation to five existing reporting guidelines and to a database of 207 published eye-tracking studies. We find that reporting guidelines vary substantially and do not match with actual reporting practices. We end by deriving a minimal, flexible reporting guideline based on empirical research (Section "empirically based minimal reporting guideline").

引用

页码：364 / 416

页数：53

共 50 条

[1] RETRACTED ARTICLE: Eye tracking: empirical foundations for a minimal reporting guideline
Kenneth Holmqvist
Saga Lee Örbom
Ignace T. C. Hooge
Diederick C. Niehorster
Robert G. Alexander
Richard Andersson
Jeroen S. Benjamins
Pieter Blignaut
Anne-Marie Brouwer
Lewis L. Chuang
Kirsten A. Dalrymple
Denis Drieghe
Matt J. Dunn
Ulrich Ettinger
Susann Fiedler
Tom Foulsham
Jos N. van der Geest
Dan Witzner Hansen
Samuel B. Hutton
Enkelejda Kasneci
Alan Kingstone
Paul C. Knox
Ellen M. Kok
Helena Lee
Joy Yeonjoo Lee
Jukka M. Leppänen
Stephen Macknik
Päivi Majaranta
Susana Martinez-Conde
Antje Nuthmann
Marcus Nyström
Jacob L. Orquin
Jorge Otero-Millan
Soon Young Park
Stanislav Popelka
Frank Proudlock
Frank Renkewitz
Austin Roorda
Michael Schulte-Mecklenbeck
Bonita Sharif
Frederick Shic
Mark Shovman
Mervyn G. Thomas
Ward Venrooij
Raimondas Zemblys
Roy S. Hessels
Behavior Research Methods, 2023, 55 : 364 - 416
[2] Retraction Note: Eye tracking: empirical foundations for a minimal reporting guideline
Kenneth Holmqvist
Saga Lee Örbom
Ignace T. C. Hooge
Diederick C. Niehorster
Robert G. Alexander
Richard Andersson
Jeroen S. Benjamins
Pieter Blignaut
Anne-Marie Brouwer
Lewis L. Chuang
Kirsten A. Dalrymple
Denis Drieghe
Matt J. Dunn
Ulrich Ettinger
Susann Fiedler
Tom Foulsham
Jos N. van der Geest
Dan Witzner Hansen
Samuel B. Hutton
Enkelejda Kasneci
Alan Kingstone
Paul C. Knox
Ellen M. Kok
Helena Lee
Joy Yeonjoo Lee
Jukka M. Leppänen
Stephen Macknik
Päivi Majaranta
Susana Martinez-Conde
Antje Nuthmann
Marcus Nyström
Jacob L. Orquin
Jorge Otero-Millan
Soon Young Park
Stanislav Popelka
Frank Proudlock
Frank Renkewitz
Austin Roorda
Michael Schulte-Mecklenbeck
Bonita Sharif
Frederick Shic
Mark Shovman
Mervyn G. Thomas
Ward Venrooij
Raimondas Zemblys
Roy S. Hessels
Behavior Research Methods, 2024, 56 : 511 - 512
[3] RETRACTION: Eye tracking: empirical foundations for a minimal reporting guideline (Retraction of Vol 55, Pg 364, 2022)
Holmqvist, Kenneth
Oerbom, Saga Lee
Hooge, Ignace T. C.
Niehorster, Diederick C.
Alexander, Robert G.
Andersson, Richard
Benjamins, Jeroen S.
Blignaut, Pieter
Brouwer, Anne-Marie
Chuang, Lewis L.
Dalrymple, Kirsten A.
Drieghe, Denis
Dunn, Matt J.
Ettinger, Ulrich
Fiedler, Susann
Foulsham, Tom
van der Geest, Jos N.
Hansen, Dan Witzner
Hutton, Samuel B.
Kasneci, Enkelejda
Kingstone, Alan
Knox, Paul C.
Kok, Ellen M.
Lee, Helena
Lee, Joy Yeonjoo
Leppanen, Jukka M.
Macknik, Stephen
Majaranta, Paeivi
Martinez-Conde, Susana
Nuthmann, Antje
Nystrom, Marcus
Orquin, Jacob L.
Otero-Millan, Jorge
Park, Soon Young
Popelka, Stanislav
Proudlock, Frank
Renkewitz, Frank
Roorda, Austin
Schulte-Mecklenbeck, Michael
Sharif, Bonita
Shic, Frederick
Shovman, Mark
Thomas, Mervyn G.
Venrooij, Ward
Zemblys, Raimondas
Hessels, Roy S.
BEHAVIOR RESEARCH METHODS, 2024, 56 (01) : 511 - 512
[4] RETRACTED: Implementation System of Human Eye Tracking Algorithm Based on FPGA (Retracted Article)
Liu, Zhong
Wang, Xin'an
Sun, Chengjun
Lu, Ken
CMC-COMPUTERS MATERIALS & CONTINUA, 2019, 58 (03): : 653 - 664
[5] RETRACTED: Analytical foundations of multimode focusing in pipes (Retracted Article)
Isla, Julio
2017 IEEE INTERNATIONAL ULTRASONICS SYMPOSIUM (IUS), 2017,
[6] RETRACTED: The Automatic Solar Tracking System (Retracted Article)
Li, Zheng-ming
Yan, Yan-yan
Xia, Xiao-hui
2011 INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE-ICEES 2011, 2011, 11
[7] Minimal reporting guideline for research involving eye tracking (2023 edition)
Dunn, Matt J.
Alexander, Robert G.
Amiebenomo, Onyekachukwu M.
Arblaster, Gemma
Atan, Denize
Erichsen, Jonathan T.
Ettinger, Ulrich
Giardini, Mario E.
Gilchrist, Iain D.
Hamilton, Ruth
Hessels, Roy S.
Hodgins, Scott
Hooge, Ignace T. C.
Jackson, Brooke S.
Lee, Helena
Macknik, Stephen L.
Martinez-Conde, Susana
Mcilreavy, Lee
Muratori, Lisa M.
Niehorster, Diederick C.
Nystrom, Marcus
Otero-Millan, Jorge
Schlussel, Michael M.
Self, Jay E.
Singh, Tarkeshwar
Smyrnis, Nikolaos
Sprenger, Andreas
BEHAVIOR RESEARCH METHODS, 2023, 56 (5) : 4351 - 4357
[8] RETRACTED: Empirical Martingale Method of Option Pricing (Retracted Article)
Xu, Yeyou
2ND IEEE INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON ADVANCED COMPUTER CONTROL (ICACC 2010), VOL. 4, 2010, : 99 - 102
[9] RETRACTED: Reporting adverse events related to cosmetic products (Retracted Article)
Katz, Linda M.
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF DERMATOLOGY, 2017, 76 (02) : E61 - E61
[10] RETRACTED: ESO Guideline on covert cerebral small vessel disease (Retracted Article)
Wardlaw, Joanna M.
Debette, Stephanie
Jokinen, Hanna
De Leeuw, Frank-Erik
Pantoni, Leonardo
Chabriat, Hugues
Staals, Julie
Doubal, Fergus
Rudilosso, Salvatore
Eppinger, Sebastian
Schilling, Sabrina
Ornello, Raffaele
Enzinger, Christian
Cordonnier, Charlotte
Taylor-Rowan, Martin
Lindgren, Arne G.
EUROPEAN STROKE JOURNAL, 2021, 6 (02) : CXI - CLXII

← 1 2 3 4 5 →