Gaps in the evidence for interventions in global drowning research

被引:0
|
作者
Vearing, Rebecca [1 ,2 ]
Scarr, Justin [3 ,4 ]
Queiroga, Ana Catarina [5 ]
Jagnoor, Jagnoor [6 ,7 ]
机构
[1] George Inst Global Hlth, Injury Div, Camperdown, NSW, Australia
[2] Univ New South Wales, Sch Populat Hlth, Sydney, NSW, Australia
[3] Royal Life Saving Soc Australia, Sydney, NSW, Australia
[4] George Inst Global Hlth, Barangaroo, NSW, Australia
[5] Univ Porto, Inst Saude Publ, EPIUnit, Porto, Portugal
[6] George Inst Global Hlth, Camperdown, NSW, Australia
[7] Univ New South Wales, Sydney, NSW, Australia
基金
英国医学研究理事会;
关键词
Interventions; Global; Drowning; Mortality; WATER SAFETY; PREVENTION PROGRAM; EDUCATION; CHILDREN; KNOWLEDGE; ATTITUDES; INCOME; INJURY; RESUSCITATION; MANAGEMENT;
D O I
10.1136/ip-2023-045215
中图分类号
R1 [预防医学、卫生学];
学科分类号
1004 ; 120402 ;
摘要
Background Since 2014, drowning has received increased political attention. Translating this political commitment to saving lives needs policy-supported evidence-informed interventions. An evidence gap map (EGM) was developed, which aims to facilitate the strategic prioritisation of future research and efficient commissioning of interventions.Methods Available evidence was sought by searching four electronic databases using drowning key terms from 2005 to 2023. Peer-reviewed studies, which measured the outcome of a drowning prevention intervention, were included in the EGM. Classification of interventions was guided by the WHO's recommendations for drowning prevention interventions and strategies. Intervention outcomes were classified into health, social, economic, policy and other supporting outcomes.Results 49 intervention studies were identified. Of these, 25 studies were conducted in high-income countries (HICs), 19 in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), 3 in both HICs and LMICs and 2 were not country specific. Interventions, which used community education, were the most common (n=29, 27%), followed by teaching school-age children swimming and water safety skills (n=13, 12%) and others combined (n=66, 61%). Majority of interventions focused on process outcomes such as knowledge acquisition (n=42, 39%) in comparison with objective outcomes such as incidence of drowning mortality (n=21, 19%). No studies reported on interventions that manage flood risks.Conclusions Knowledge gaps of effective drowning prevention interventions were identified using an EGM, emphasising the need for methodological advancements reporting on outcomes measures, implementation research and targeted research among high-risk populations in LMICs.
引用
收藏
页数:10
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Adolescent Health Interventions: Conclusions, Evidence Gaps, and Research Priorities
    Salam, Rehana A.
    Das, Jai K.
    Lassi, Zohra S.
    Bhutta, Zulfiqar A.
    JOURNAL OF ADOLESCENT HEALTH, 2016, 59 (04) : S88 - S92
  • [2] EFFECTIVENESS OF CHILDHOOD DROWNING PREVENTION INTERVENTIONS: EVIDENCE REVIEW
    Alonge, Olakunle
    Bishai, David
    Wadhwaniya, Shirin
    Agrawal, Priyanka
    Rahman, Fazlur
    Rahman, Amin
    Baset, Kamran
    Bhuiyan, Al-Amin
    Talab, Abu
    Hoque, Emdad Md Dewan
    Salam, Shumona Sharmin
    Islam, Irteja
    Rahman, Qazi Sadeq-Ur
    El-Arifeen, Shams
    Hyder, Adnan A.
    INJURY PREVENTION, 2018, 24 : A162 - A162
  • [3] ESTABLISHING AN EVIDENCE BASE FOR DROWNING INTERVENTIONS IN THE REPUBLIC OF IRELAND
    Kervick, Aoife
    Dix, Dani
    Walters, Thomas
    Sweeney, Roger
    Sarma, Kiran
    INJURY PREVENTION, 2016, 22 : A297 - A297
  • [4] Systematic reviews of occupational therapy interventions: summarizing research evidence and highlighting the gaps
    Hackett, Katie
    Newton, Julia
    Rapley, Tim
    Deane, Katherine
    Deary, Vincent
    Ng, Wan-Fai
    BRITISH JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY, 2014, 77 (09) : 479 - 482
  • [5] Evidence and evidence gaps in assessments and interventions in areas related to social work research and practice - an overview of four evidence maps
    Hellberg, Christel
    Larsson, Sam
    Bertilsson, Goran
    Domeij, Helena
    Tholen, Susanna Larsson
    Karrman-Fredriksson, Maja
    Ahlstrom, Gerd
    Dahlberg, Lena
    Karlsson, Patrik
    Nybom, Jenny
    Starke, Mikaela
    Ohrvall, Ann-Marie
    Fahlstrom, Gunilla
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF SOCIAL WORK, 2023, 26 (05) : 882 - 895
  • [6] The ghost in the data: Evidence gaps and the problem of fake drugs in global health research
    Hodges, Sarah
    Garnett, Emma
    GLOBAL PUBLIC HEALTH, 2020, 15 (08) : 1103 - 1118
  • [7] Tailoring Interventions: Examining the Evidence and Identifying Gaps
    Gagliardi, Anna R.
    JOURNAL OF CONTINUING EDUCATION IN THE HEALTH PROFESSIONS, 2011, 31 (04) : 276 - 282
  • [8] Global Cardiovascular Research: Gaps and Opportunities
    Maha Inam
    Zainab Samad
    Elizabeth M. Vaughan
    Aysha Almas
    Bashir Hanif
    Abdul Mannan Minhas
    Zeerak Jarrar
    Fatima Zohra Habib
    Sana Sheikh
    Dongshan Zhu
    Salim S. Virani
    Current Cardiology Reports, 2023, 25 : 1831 - 1838
  • [9] BEST-EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS: EFFECTIVENESS OF CHILD DROWNING PREVENTION INTERVENTIONS
    Ashraf, Lamisa
    Zia, Nukhba
    Agrawal, Priyanka
    Green, Abigail
    Vincenten, Joanne
    MacKay, Morag
    Bachani, Abdulgafoor M.
    INJURY PREVENTION, 2022, 28 : A73 - A73
  • [10] Global Cardiovascular Research: Gaps and Opportunities
    Inam, Maha
    Samad, Zainab
    Vaughan, Elizabeth M.
    Almas, Aysha
    Hanif, Bashir
    Minhas, Abdul Mannan
    Jarrar, Zeerak
    Habib, Fatima Zohra
    Sheikh, Sana
    Zhu, Dongshan
    Virani, Salim S.
    CURRENT CARDIOLOGY REPORTS, 2023, 25 (12) : 1831 - 1838