A comparative performance analysis of sensible thermal energy storage (with concentrated solar field and sCO2 Brayton Cycle) and hydrogen energy storage (with solar PV field)

Utility scale energy storage is an integral part of renewable energy installations to achieve sustainable and reliable transition to a net zero energy economy. There exists a myriad of such storage solutions each having unique characteristics. This paper attempts at a systems level quantitative study and comparison between two different energy storage technologies, Thermal Energy Storage System (TESS) which is already mature, and Hydrogen Energy Storage System (HESS) which gained a lot of momentum recently, with the former coupled with a concentrated parabolic trough solar field using molten salt as heat transfer fluid and a power block running on high efficiency sCO2 Brayton cycle while the latter is coupled with a solar photovoltaic (PV) field. So that comparisons can be made on similar scale, both the systems are normalized on the total equipment area used for capturing incident solar irradiation, i.e., total aperture area for the PTC field and total flat surface area of PV modules. Both the systems are subjected to year-long variations of ambient conditions and solar irradiance and off-design performances are simulated over various seasons. The results show superior performance of TESS in terms of roundtrip efficiency (96% as opposed to 32% with HESS) which also results in superior capacity utilization factor (CUF of 64.5% and 48% for TESS and HESS respectively) and better specific energy and energy density. However, HESS offers virtually infinite idling time where TESS has a shorter self-discharge time (17 h), and better power performance (specific power and power density) in 10MWe output range.