A comparative study on precision of direct evaluations, the Pairwise Comparisons Method and the Best-Worst Method

被引：1
|
作者：
Cavallo, Bice [1 ]
Ishizaka, Alessio [2 ]
机构：
[1] Univ Napoli Federico II, Naples, Italy
[2] NEOMA Business Sch, Paris, France
来源：
OMEGA-INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT SCIENCE | 2025年 / 130卷
关键词：
Multi-criteria decision making; Pairwise Comparisons Method; Best-Worst Method; DECISION-MAKING; COMPARISON MATRICES; DERIVING WEIGHTS; FRAMEWORK;
D O I：
10.1016/j.omega.2024.103175
中图分类号：
C93 [管理学];
学科分类号：
12 ; 1201 ; 1202 ; 120202 ;
摘要：
The aim of this paper is to design, carry out and analyze an experiment with over 100 respondents to measure the precision of the respondents when they compare (by evaluation) the areas of nine geometric figures and five distances between cities by using direct evaluations, Pairwise Comparisons Method and Best-Worst Method. The outcomes of the experiment indicate that the direct evaluations are the most imprecise and that there is not statistically significant difference between Best-Worst Method and Pairwise Comparisons Method.
引用
收藏
页数：8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] The behavioural best-worst method
    Kheybari, Siamak
    Ishizaka, Alessio
    EXPERT SYSTEMS WITH APPLICATIONS, 2022, 209
  • [2] The Balancing Role of Best and Worst in Best-Worst Method
    Rezaei, Jafar
    ADVANCES IN BEST-WORST METHOD, BWM2021, 2022, : 1 - 15
  • [3] Best-worst Tradeoff method
    Liang, Fuqi
    Brunelli, Matteo
    Rezaei, Jafar
    INFORMATION SCIENCES, 2022, 610 : 957 - 976
  • [4] A Novel Extension of Best-Worst Method With Intuitionistic Fuzzy Reference Comparisons
    Wan, Shuping
    Dong, Jiuying
    IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON FUZZY SYSTEMS, 2022, 30 (06) : 1698 - 1711
  • [5] Best-worst method for robot selection
    Ali, Asif
    Rashid, Tabasam
    SOFT COMPUTING, 2021, 25 (01) : 563 - 583
  • [6] The best-worst method for the study of preferences: Theory and applications
    Marley, Anthony A. J.
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY, 2008, 43 (3-4) : 168 - 168
  • [7] The best-worst method for the study of preferences Theory and application
    Marley, A. A. J.
    COGNITION AND NEUROPSYCHOLOGY: INTERNATIONAL PERSPECTIVES ON PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE, VOL 1, 2010, : 147 - 157
  • [8] Priority ranking for the best-worst method
    Tu, Jiancheng
    Wu, Zhibin
    Pedrycz, Witold
    INFORMATION SCIENCES, 2023, 635 : 42 - 55
  • [9] An analytical framework for the best-worst method
    Wu, Qun
    Liu, Xinwang
    Zhou, Ligang
    Qin, Jindong
    Rezaei, Jafar
    OMEGA-INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT SCIENCE, 2024, 123
  • [10] Improving the Best-Worst Method Based on Optimal Completion of Incomplete Pairwise Comparison Matrix
    Wu, Shihui
    He, Bo
    Liu, Xiaodong
    IEEE ACCESS, 2022, 10 : 127284 - 127296
12345