A male patient in his 60s, with a history of tobacco use, presented with fever, weight loss, and cough, and was ultimately diagnosed with histoplasmosis. Initial treatment with itraconazole (ITZ) led to symptom improvement. However, two months later, he returned with lower extremity swelling and dyspnea. Imaging showed pleural effusions and reduced ejection fraction, suggesting itraconazole-induced cardiac toxicity. Transition to voriconazole and initiation of guideline -directed medical therapy improved symptoms. This case report delves into the cardiac side effects of itraconazole, notably heart failure, and elucidates the potential underlying mechanisms. Our goal is to emphasize the importance of monitoring patients on itraconazole for potential cardiac complications, necessitating timely intervention to mitigate adverse outcomes.