Core outcome measurement set for research and clinical practice in post-COVID-19 condition (long COVID) in children and young people: an international Delphi consensus study "PC-COS Children"

被引:11
|
作者
Seylanova, Nina
Chernyavskaya, Anastasia [1 ,2 ]
Degtyareva, Natalia [3 ]
Mursalova, Aigun [4 ]
Ajam, Ali [4 ]
Xiao, Lin [4 ]
Aktulaeva, Khazhar [4 ]
Roshchin, Philipp [4 ]
Bobkova, Polina [4 ]
Aiyegbusi, Olalekan Lee [4 ]
Anbu, Anbarasu Theodore [5 ]
Apfelbacher, Christian [6 ]
Asadi-Pooya, Ali Akbar [7 ,8 ]
Ashkenazi-Hoffnung, Liat [9 ]
Brackel, Caroline [10 ,11 ]
Buonsenso, Danilo [12 ,13 ]
de Groote, Wouter [14 ]
Diaz, Janet, V [15 ]
Dona, Daniele [15 ]
Galvin, Audrey Dunn [16 ]
Genuneit, Jon [17 ]
Goss, Helen [18 ]
Hughes, Sarah E. [19 ]
Jones, Christina J. [20 ]
Kuppalli, Krutika [15 ]
Malone, Laura A. [21 ,22 ]
Mcfarland, Sammie [19 ]
Needham, Dale M. [23 ,24 ,25 ]
Nekliudov, Nikita [26 ]
Nicholson, Timothy R. [27 ]
Oliveira, Carlos R. [28 ,29 ,30 ]
Schiess, Nicoline [31 ]
Segal, Terry Y. [32 ]
Sigfrid, Louise [33 ]
Thorne, Claire [34 ]
Vijverberg, Susanne [35 ]
Warner, John O. [36 ]
Were, Wilson Milton [15 ]
Williamson, Paula R. [36 ]
Munblit, Daniel [3 ,37 ,38 ,39 ]
机构
[1] Sechenov Univ, Sechenov First Moscow State Med Univ, Dept Paediat & Paediat Rheumatol, Moscow, Russia
[2] Natl Med Res Ctr Childrens Hlth, Moscow, Russia
[3] Sechenov Univ, Sechenov First Moscow State Med Univ, Inst Childs Hlth, Dept Paediat & Paediat Infect Dis, Moscow, Russia
[4] Univ Birmingham, Birmingham, England
[5] Alder Hey Childrens NHS Fdn Trust, Liverpool, England
[6] Univ Magdeburg, Magdeburg, Germany
[7] Shiraz Univ Med Sci, Epilepsy Res Ctr, Shiraz, Iran
[8] Thomas Jefferson Univ, Jefferson Comprehens Epilepsy Ctr, Philadelphia, PA USA
[9] Schneider Childrens Med Ctr Israel, Petah Tiqwa, Israel
[10] Univ Amsterdam, Emma Childrens Hosp, Dept Pediat Pulmonol, Med Ctr, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[11] Tergooi Hosp, Dept Pediat, Blaricum, Netherlands
[12] Univ Cattolica Sacro Cuore, Ctr Global Hlth Res & Studies, Rome, Italy
[13] Fdn Policlin Univ A Gemelli IRCCS, Dept Woman & Child Hlth & Publ Hlth, Rome, Italy
[14] WHO, Geneva, Switzerland
[15] Univ Padua, Dept Womens & Childrens Hlth, Padua, Italy
[16] Univ Cork, Cork, Ireland
[17] Univ Leipzig, Med Fac, Dept Pediat, Pediat Epidemiol, Leipzig, Germany
[18] Long Covid Kids Charity, Salisbury, England
[19] Univ Birmingham, Inst Appl Hlth Res, Birmingham, England
[20] Univ Surrey, Sch Psychol, Guildford, England
[21] Kennedy Krieger Inst, Baltimore, MD USA
[22] Johns Hopkins Univ, Dept Phys Med & Rehabil, Baltimore, MD USA
[23] Johns Hopkins Univ, Outcomes Crit Illness & Surg OACIS Res Grp, Baltimore, MD USA
[24] Johns Hopkins Univ, Sch Med, Pulm & Crit Care Med, Dept Med, Baltimore, MD USA
[25] Johns Hopkins Univ, Sch Med, Phys Med & Rehabil, Baltimore, MD USA
[26] Univ Washington, Inst Hlth Metr & Evaluat, Seattle, WA USA
[27] Kings Coll London, Inst Psychiat Psychol & Neurosci, London, England
[28] Yale Univ, Sch Med, Dept Pediat, Infect Dis Sect, New Haven, CT 06510 USA
[29] Yale Sch Publ Hlth, Dept Biostat, Div Hlth Informat, New Haven, CT 06510 USA
[30] Yale New Haven Childrens Hosp, New Haven, CT USA
[31] WHO, Brain Hlth Unit, Dept Mental Hlth & Subst Use, CH-1202 Geneva, Switzerland
[32] Univ Coll London Hosp NHS Fdn Trust, London, England
[33] Univ Oxford, ISARIC Global Support Ctr, Ctr Trop Med & Global Hlth, Oxford, England
[34] Univ Coll London GOS Inst Child Hlth, Populat Policy & Practice Res & Teaching Dept, London, England
[35] Amsterdam Univ Med Ctr, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[36] Imperial Coll London, London, England
[37] Univ Liverpool, Dept Hlth Data Sci, MRC NIHR Trials Methodol Res Partnership, Liverpool, England
[38] Kings Coll London, Florence Nightingale Fac Nursing Midwifery & Palli, Div Care Long Term Condit, London, England
[39] Res & Clin Ctr Neuropsychiat, Moscow, Russia
基金
美国国家卫生研究院;
关键词
D O I
10.1183/13993003.01761-2023
中图分类号
R56 [呼吸系及胸部疾病];
学科分类号
摘要
The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic substantially impacted different age groups, with children and young people not exempted. Many have experienced enduring health consequences. Presently, there is no consensus on the health outcomes to assess in children and young people with postCOVID-19 condition. Furthermore, it is unclear which measurement instruments are appropriate for use in research and clinical management of children and young people with post-COVID-19. To address these unmet needs, we conducted a consensus study, aiming to develop a core outcome set (COS) and an associated core outcome measurement set (COMS) for evaluating post-COVID-19 condition in children and young people. Our methodology comprised of two phases. In phase 1 (to create a COS), we performed an extensive literature review and categorisation of outcomes, and prioritised those outcomes in a two -round online modified Delphi process followed by a consensus meeting. In phase 2 (to create the COMS), we performed another modified Delphi consensus process to evaluate measurement instruments for previously defined core outcomes from phase 1, followed by an online consensus workshop to finalise recommendations regarding the most appropriate instruments for each core outcome. In phase 1, 214 participants from 37 countries participated, with 154 (72%) contributing to both Delphi rounds. The subsequent online consensus meeting resulted in a final COS which encompassed seven critical outcomes: fatigue; post -exertion symptoms; work/occupational and study changes; as well as functional changes, symptoms, and conditions relating to cardiovascular, neuro-cognitive, gastrointestinal and physical outcomes. In phase 2, 11 international experts were involved in a modified Delphi process, selecting measurement instruments for a subsequent online consensus workshop where 30 voting participants discussed and independently scored the selected instruments. As a result of this consensus process, four instruments met a priori consensus criteria for inclusion: PedsQL multidimensional fatigue scale for "fatigue"; PedsQL gastrointestinal symptom scales for "gastrointestinal"; PedsQL cognitive functioning scale for "neurocognitive" and EQ-5D for "physical functioning". Despite proposing outcome measurement instruments for the remaining three core outcomes ("cardiovascular", "post-exertional malaise", "work/occupational and study changes"), a consensus was not achieved. Our international, consensus -based initiative presents a robust framework for evaluating post-COVID-19 condition in children and young people in research and clinical practice via a rigorously defined COS and associated COMS. It will aid in the uniform measurement and reporting of relevant health outcomes worldwide.
引用
收藏
页数:15
相关论文
共 17 条
  • [1] A core outcome set for post-COVID-19 condition in adults for use in clinical practice and research: an international Delphi consensus study
    Munblit, Daniel
    Nicholson, Timothy
    Akrami, Athena
    Apfelbacher, Christian
    Chen, Jessica
    De Groote, Wouter
    Diaz, Janet, V
    Gorst, Sarah L.
    Harman, Nicola
    Kokorina, Alisa
    Olliaro, Piero
    Parr, Callum
    Preller, Jacobus
    Schiess, Nicoline
    Schmitt, Jochen
    Seylanova, Nina
    Simpson, Frances
    Tong, Allison
    Needham, Dale M.
    Williamson, Paula R.
    LANCET RESPIRATORY MEDICINE, 2022, 10 (07): : 715 - 724
  • [2] Core outcome measurement instruments for use in clinical and research settings for adults with post-COVID-19 condition: an international Delphi consensus study
    Gorst, Sarah L.
    Seylanova, Nina
    Dodd, Susanna R.
    Harman, Nicola L.
    O'Hara, Margaret
    Terwee, Caroline B.
    Williamson, Paula R.
    Needham, Dale M.
    Munblit, Daniel
    Nicholson, Timothy R.
    LANCET RESPIRATORY MEDICINE, 2023, 11 (12): : 1101 - 1114
  • [3] Long COVID (post-COVID-19 condition) in children: a modified Delphi process
    Stephenson, Terence
    Allin, Benjamin
    Nugawela, Manjula D.
    Rojas, Natalia
    Dalrymple, Emma
    Pereira, Snehal Pinto
    Soni, Manas
    Knight, Marian
    Cheung, Emily Y.
    Heyman, Isobel
    Shafran, Roz
    ARCHIVES OF DISEASE IN CHILDHOOD, 2022, 107 (07) : 674 - 680
  • [4] Risk factors for post-COVID-19 condition (Long Covid) in children: a prospective cohort study
    Morello, Rosa
    Mariani, Francesco
    Mastrantoni, Luca
    De Rose, Cristina
    Zampino, Giuseppe
    Munblit, Daniel
    Sigfrid, Louise
    Valentini, Piero
    Buonsenso, Danilo
    ECLINICALMEDICINE, 2023, 59
  • [5] Studying the post-COVID-19 condition: research challenges, strategies, and importance of Core Outcome Set development
    Daniel Munblit
    Timothy R. Nicholson
    Dale M. Needham
    Nina Seylanova
    Callum Parr
    Jessica Chen
    Alisa Kokorina
    Louise Sigfrid
    Danilo Buonsenso
    Shinjini Bhatnagar
    Ramachandran Thiruvengadam
    Ann M. Parker
    Jacobus Preller
    Sergey Avdeev
    Frederikus A. Klok
    Allison Tong
    Janet V. Diaz
    Wouter De Groote
    Nicoline Schiess
    Athena Akrami
    Frances Simpson
    Piero Olliaro
    Christian Apfelbacher
    Regis Goulart Rosa
    Jennifer R. Chevinsky
    Sharon Saydah
    Jochen Schmitt
    Alla Guekht
    Sarah L. Gorst
    Jon Genuneit
    Luis Felipe Reyes
    Alan Asmanov
    Margaret E. O’Hara
    Janet T. Scott
    Melina Michelen
    Charitini Stavropoulou
    John O. Warner
    Margaret Herridge
    Paula R. Williamson
    BMC Medicine, 20
  • [6] Studying the post-COVID-19 condition: research challenges, strategies, and importance of Core Outcome Set development
    Munblit, Daniel
    Nicholson, Timothy R.
    Needham, Dale M.
    Seylanova, Nina
    Parr, Callum
    Chen, Jessica
    Kokorina, Alisa
    Sigfrid, Louise
    Buonsenso, Danilo
    Bhatnagar, Shinjini
    Thiruvengadam, Ramachandran
    Parker, Ann M.
    Preller, Jacobus
    Avdeev, Sergey
    Klok, Frederikus A.
    Tong, Allison
    Diaz, Janet V.
    De Groote, Wouter
    Schiess, Nicoline
    Akrami, Athena
    Simpson, Frances
    Olliaro, Piero
    Apfelbacher, Christian
    Rosa, Regis Goulart
    Chevinsky, Jennifer R.
    Saydah, Sharon
    Schmitt, Jochen
    Guekht, Alla
    Gorst, Sarah L.
    Genuneit, Jon
    Reyes, Luis Felipe
    Asmanov, Alan
    O'Hara, Margaret E.
    Scott, Janet T.
    Michelen, Melina
    Stavropoulou, Charitini
    Warner, John O.
    Herridge, Margaret
    Williamson, Paula R.
    BMC MEDICINE, 2022, 20 (01)
  • [7] Post-Covid-19 condition (Long Covid) in children and young people 12 months after infection or reinfection with the Omicron variant: a prospective observational study
    Pinto Pereira, Snehal M.
    Nugawela, Manjula D.
    Stephenson, Terence
    Foret-Bruno, Paul
    Dalrymple, Emma
    Xu, Laila
    Whittaker, Elizabeth
    Heyman, Isobel
    Ford, Tamsin
    Segal, Terry
    Chalder, Trudie
    Ladhani, Shamez N.
    Mensah, Anna A.
    Mcowat, Kelsey
    Simmons, Ruth
    Shafran, Roz
    SCIENTIFIC REPORTS, 2024, 14 (01)
  • [8] Post-COVID-19 condition at 6 months and COVID-19 vaccination in non-hospitalised children and young people
    Pereira, Snehal M. Pinto
    Nugawela, Manjula D.
    Rojas, Natalia K.
    Shafran, Roz
    McOwat, Kelsey
    Simmons, Ruth
    Ford, Tamsin
    Heyman, Isobel
    Ladhani, Shamez N.
    Cheung, Emily Y.
    Fox-Smith, Lana
    Dalrymple, Emma
    Stephenson, Terence
    ARCHIVES OF DISEASE IN CHILDHOOD, 2023, 108 (04) : 289 - 295
  • [9] Fifteen-minute consultation: Managing post-COVID-19 syndrome (long COVID) in children and young people
    Wacks, Michael
    Wortley, Elizabeth
    Gregorowski, Anna
    Segal, Terry Y.
    Whittaker, Elizabeth
    ARCHIVES OF DISEASE IN CHILDHOOD-EDUCATION AND PRACTICE EDITION, 2024, 109 (01): : 29 - 34
  • [10] A core outcome set for bronchiectasis in children and adolescents for use in clinical research: an international consensus study
    Chang, Anne B.
    Boyd, Jeanette
    Bush, Andrew
    Hill, Adam
    Powell, Zena
    Zacharasiewicz, Angela
    Alexopoulou, Efthymia
    Collaro, Andrew J.
    Chalmers, James D.
    Constant, Carolina
    Douros, Konstantinos
    Fortescue, Rebecca
    Griese, Matthias
    Grigg, Jonathan
    Hector, Andreas
    Karadag, Bulent
    Mazulov, Oleksandr
    Midulla, Fabio
    Moeller, Alexander
    Proesmans, Marijke
    Wilson, Christine
    Yerkovich, Stephanie
    Kantar, Ahmad
    Grimwood, Keith
    LANCET RESPIRATORY MEDICINE, 2024, 12 (01): : 78 - 88