Geochemical and thermodynamic constraints on the genesis of coexisting alkaline and tholeiitic basalts from Datong, North China: Implication for compositional diversity of continental intraplate basalts

Continental intraplate basalts usually exhibit diverse compositions varying from silica-deficient alkaline basalts to silica-excess tholeiites. However, the mechanism of compositional diversity remains controversial. Here, we conducted comprehensive petrology, mineral chemistry, whole-rock geochemistry, and Sr-Nd-Hf isotopic compositions, as well as thermodynamic modeling for the coexisting Datong alkaline and tholeiitic basalts, North China, to put constraints on the source characteristics and melting conditions of these basalts. The alkaline basalts and tholeiites have contrasting major elemental and Sr-Nd-Hf isotopic compositions (Sr-87/Sr-86, 0.703431-0.703603 vs. 0.703912-0.704010; epsilon(Nd), 5.5-7.0 vs. 2.9-4.8; epsilon(Hf), 9.5-10.6 vs. 8.2-9.6) and trace-element patterns. The observed compositional differences could be explained by neither magmatic processes (e.g., assimilation and/or fractional crystallization), varying melting degrees due to lithospheric thickness variations, nor the melt-peridotite interaction. Instead, lithological heterogeneous mantle sources containing different types of pyroxenite should be considered to account for the compositional diversity, as indicated by olivine (high Ni, Zn/Fe, and low Mn/Zn) and whole-rock chemistry (low CaO, high Fe/Mn, FC3MS, and FCKANTMS ratios). The incompatible trace element-based thermodynamic modeling was carried out to put quantitative constraints on the mantle source characteristics and melting conditions. The modeling results suggest that the source of alkaline basalts contains 30% silica-deficient pyroxenite +70% lherzolite with melting pressure and temperatures of 2 GPa, 1370 degrees C, whereas the tholeiites have 15% silica-excess pyroxenite +85% harzburgite in the source with melting conditions of 1.5 GPa, 1425 degrees C. The estimations, together with the thermobarometric calculations using major-element compositions, suggest that the tholeiitic and alkaline basalts were generated by melting of lithological heterogeneous mantle sources under lithosphere with different thicknesses. The lithological heterogeneity originated from recycled components from historical peripheral subducted plates, and melting of such lithological heterogeneity is likely related to asthenosphere upwelling and convection induced by the deeply subducted Pacific slab. Our study emphasizes the fundamental role of source lithological heterogeneity in the generation of co-existing Datong alkaline and tholeiitic basalts and may provide insights into the origin of compositional diversity of other continental intraplate basalts.