Innocent or Noninnocent Interactions of the Cations on Spin-Frustrated Lindqvist Hexavanadate: Structural Analysis and Magnetic Properties

We report the effect of the countercations in three crystalline networks based on a mixed-valence hexavanadate fragment containing 3 V-IV and 3 V-V centers and functionalized with three molecules of tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane, giving the polyanion [(V3V3O10)-V-IV-O-IV{(OCH2)(3)CNH2}(3)](2-). The mixed-valence hexavanadate is crystallized using three different cations, obtaining [H3O](2)[(V3V3O10)-V-IV-O-IV{(OCH2)(3)CNH2}(3)]<middle dot>6H(2)O, 1, Na-2[(V3V3O10)-V-IV-O-IV{(OCH2)(3)CNH2}(3)]<middle dot>9H(2)O, 2, and [n-Bu4N](2)[(V3V3O10)-V-IV-O-IV{(OCH2)(3)CNH2}(3)]<middle dot>(H2O)(DMF), 3. The structural characterization shows that 1-3 present perfect equilateral arrangements of the paramagnetic triangles of V-IV, thus showing structural spin frustration. The supramolecular interaction modulates the studied magnetic properties depending on the size and distribution of the cations around the hexavanadate fragment. Theoretical calculations demonstrated that the three studied compounds present the ground state doublets degenerated. Compound 3 shows a plateau below 16 K in the chi T-m(T) plot, showing the S = 1/2 ground state due to the antiferromagnetic interactions in the triangle, whereas in compounds 1 and 2, the plateau is absent and the chi T-m product decreases near zero at 2 K. In 1 and 2, the magnetic moment decreases at low temperatures due to antiferromagnetic interactions of the spin triangles in the tetrahedral supramolecular arrangement.