SECOND-PERSONAL REASON-GIVING

David Enoch has recently objected to Stephen Darwall's account of secondpersonal reason- giving that the phenomena that Darwall focuses on can be fully explained without resorting to second- personal reasons. In this paper, I shall argue, against Enoch, that second-personal reason- giving matters. My account of second- personal reason-giving diff ers from Darwall's, however, as it accepts that some of the phenomena Darwall focuses on can be reduced to the more standard form of reason-giving.